Barkbox vs Super Chewer: A Comprehensive Comparison

Barkbox and Super Chewer are two popular subscription boxes for dogs, but they cater to different needs and preferences. Barkbox is a more general subscription service that sends a monthly box of toys, treats, and chews tailored to your dog's size and preferences.

Super Chewer, on the other hand, is designed specifically for aggressive chewers, with a focus on durable toys and treats that can withstand heavy chewing. The box is curated with a focus on the most durable materials and designs.

Barkbox offers a more affordable monthly subscription, starting at $25 per month, while Super Chewer's prices start at $35 per month. Super Chewer's higher price point reflects the more durable materials and toys included in the box.

Ultimately, the choice between Barkbox and Super Chewer depends on your dog's individual needs and preferences.

Barkbox is a monthly subscription box service that delivers a package of dog toys, treats, and chews to your doorstep. Each box is tailored to your dog's size and dietary needs.

The boxes are curated by a team of dog lovers who select high-quality, durable toys and tasty treats to keep your furry friend entertained and satisfied. They also offer a range of plans to suit different budgets and preferences.

Barkbox is designed for dogs of all ages and sizes, from small to large breeds, and their boxes are filled with goodies that cater to various dietary needs, including grain-free and limited-ingredient options.

Each BarkBox box contains 2 original themed plush toys, 2 full-sized treat bags, and a crunchy chew stick. These plush toys are made with a variety of textured fabrics, stretchy and soft t-shirt rope, and short and long fuzz.

BarkBox's plushies are often stuffed with crinkle paper, classic squeakers, or spiky balls. Each box has an exciting monthly and/or seasonal theme, like colorful desert creatures or rough-n-tumble college football mascots.

Django's latest box was filled with Jurassic World-themed dog toys and treats. The box included a "furry-feathered" and squeaky plush Pyroraptor toy, a squeaky and crinkly Beta dinosaur, and a super fluffy and bird-like Therizinosaurus.

The treats in a BarkBox are also high-quality and unique. Django's box included a bag of 'Raptor Scraps' Turkey Recipe Dog Biscuits with Mixed Berries and a bag of 'Raptor Scraps' Chicken Recipe Dog Jerky.

If your pup loves to pull the stuffing out of his plush dog toys, Bark's Happy Team can upgrade your box to the More Durable Classic plan for free. This plan includes stronger stitching and a liner in the plush toys.

Here's a comparison of the contents of two BarkBox boxes:

BarkBox is a fantastic deal when you sign up for a multi-month subscription. You can lock in a significant 35%-45% discount by committing to a 6 or 12-month plan.

Each BarkBox has a retail value of around $40, but with a 12-month subscription plan at $23/box, you save 43% off the retail price. If you pay upfront, you save an extra 10-20%.

Signing up for a 6 or 12-month plan also gives you access to free shipping in the contiguous 48 United States.

Here's a breakdown of the prices for a 6 and 12-month subscription plan:

BarkBox offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee, and their customer service is quick to help via text, live chat, and email. If your dog isn't a super chewer, BarkBox also has a standard box option.

If you're currently spending around $35 per month on dog toys, a service like BarkBox could save you money if you sign up for a semiannual or annual plan.

The product and quality of BarkBox and Super Chewer are worth considering.

BarkBox includes two small toys, two midsized bags of treats, and one chew for over $40. I'd estimate that's less value for the price compared to buying the same items individually.

The toys in BarkBox are often plush and tied into the cityscape theme, but may not be durable enough for heavy chewers. I was disappointed to receive a soft Chinese takeout box toy that I'm hesitant to give to my dog to play with.

BarkBox offers a variety of flavors in their edible items, including savory and sweet options, and they take allergens into account when selecting treats.

Super Chewer is a subscription box service that sends high-quality, durable dog toys and chews to your doorstep.

Their toys are made with tough materials that can withstand aggressive chewers, such as rubber and nylon.

The company offers a range of toys, including bully sticks, raw hide chews, and plush toys.

Each box is curated to provide a variety of textures and flavors to keep your dog engaged and interested.

Super Chewer's toys are designed to be long-lasting, with some lasting up to 100 hours of chewing time.

The quality of treats in these subscription boxes is a big deal. Some boxes offer a better variety of treats than others.

Bullymake's boxes come with three packages of treats: two small varieties and one larger one. This is a nice bonus, but not necessarily the most essential part of the box.

Super Chewer, on the other hand, blows Bullymake out of the water with more treats. They send two full-size bags of tasty treats every month, which is a great deal for the price.

The Kong Box only comes with one package of small treats, which is a bit disappointing. However, these small treats could be useful for training.

Some boxes, like Super Chewer, also offer the option to customize treats for allergy and diet preferences. This is a great feature for pet owners who need to be mindful of their dog's dietary needs.

Work-to-Eat toys are a big part of my training philosophy, allowing dogs to functionally engage in parts of the prey drive sequence like foraging and dissecting.

Bullymake consistently provides a work-to-eat toy in their boxes, but the holes are small, making it hard to get the food out, especially when you want to fill the toy with kibble or meat.

The Bark Box toy was neat, with a variable opening that made it more or less challenging, but it's entry-level stuff that might be good for some, but not for dogs like mine.

Here's an interesting read: Difference between Male and Female German Shepherds

Kong has made their name on their flagship Work-to-Eat toy, and they beat out both Bark Box and Bullymake because the box comes with two work-to-eat toys.

The only downside with Kong is that they tend to undersize their recommendations, so it's best to choose a size larger than they suggest.

For example, I recommended a size larger than they do, and the toy they sent along was an excellent example of that principle - it only holds about half a cup of food, whereas an extra large Kong holds just under a cup.

A fresh viewpoint: Which Is Smaller Miniature or Toy Poodle

The quality of products in subscription boxes like BarkBox can vary. Some boxes may include a large number of items, but the quality and durability of those items can be a concern.

For example, the reviewer of BarkBox received two small toys, two midsized bags of treats, and one chew for over $40, which might be considered underwhelming for the price.

The toys included in the box were cute, but they were also soft and might not last long with a dog that likes to play tug-of-war. The Chinese takeout box toy had a soft exterior and squishy dumplings that might not be suitable for a dog that likes to chew.

On the other hand, some subscription boxes, like Super Chewer, offer toys made of durable materials like specialty nylon and ballistic fabric that can withstand even the most determined chewers.

The edible items in BarkBox, such as the treats and chew, came in a variety of flavors and were free from common allergens like beef, which is a plus for pet owners with dietary restrictions.

BarkBox has its pros and cons.

One of the main advantages is timely delivery, which ensures that your furry friend receives their treats and toys on schedule. Engaging box themes with unique toys and a wide variety of treat flavors are also major perks. You'll also appreciate the good balance of items in each box and the variety of subscription options available.

However, there are some drawbacks to consider. The price without a subscription doesn't feel like you're getting the best value, and the soft toys may not be durable for heavy playtime. Additionally, shipping isn't free for one-time purchases, which can add to the overall cost.

Here are some key points to consider:

Both Super Chewer and Bullymake toys have proven to be extremely long-lasting.

Made of specialty nylon, durable rubber, and ballistic fabric, these toys have withstood even Hank's attempts to destroy them.

Hank has yet to successfully destroy any of the Super Chewer or Bullymake toys.

Both companies offer replacements if one of their toys is destroyed.

Super Chewer and Bullymake toys are durable enough to be a worthy adversary to Hank.

It's clear that both companies have put a lot of thought into making their toys long-lasting.

BarkBox has its share of pros and cons. One of the biggest advantages is the timely delivery of the box, which is always a plus. The box themes are also engaging and come with unique toys that are sure to delight your furry friend.

Here are some of the pros of BarkBox:

However, there are some drawbacks to consider. The price of the box without a subscription can be a bit steep, and you might not feel like you're getting the best value for your money.

BarkBox and Super Chewer are two popular dog subscription boxes that cater to different needs. Super Chewer is a great option for dogs that are super chewers, as it includes two tough toys and two full-sized bags of treats made in the USA or Canada.

One of the main advantages of Super Chewer is its fun themes and designs, which can keep your dog engaged and interested. For example, boxes have fun themes like Barkbuster Movie Night, Spongebob Squarepants, and Give N’ Thanks.

Super Chewer also offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee, which is a big plus. If a toy isn't tough enough for your super chewer, BarkBox will replace it for free, no questions asked. This is a great feature for dog owners who want to ensure their dog is getting the best possible products.

Discover more: Doberman Pinscher vs Great Dane

Here's a comparison of the pricing plans for both BarkBox and Super Chewer:

Overall, Super Chewer seems to be a great option for dog owners who want a subscription box that caters to their dog's specific needs.

Bullymake offers the best dog subscription box for heavy chewers. They have a toy-only option and competitive prices.

You can choose the toy materials your dog likes best and change the delivery frequency. Bullymake ships a themed box the next business day after you place your order.

Their toy-only box is a perfect solution for power chewers like Barley. Four new Bullymake toys each month are a great way to keep your dog entertained and satisfied.

Bullymake offers four types of toys: nylon, rubber, rope, and ballistic. Depending on your dog's toy and play preferences, one or two styles may be a better fit.

Here's a summary of Bullymake's pros and cons:

Bullymake and BoxDog are two popular pet subscription boxes that cater to our furry friends' needs. Bullymake offers a 1-month subscription for $45, which is the same price as BoxDog and BarkBox Super Chewer.

The cost of a 6-month subscription varies between the two companies, with Bullymake charging $33 and BoxDog charging $40.

One of the standout features of Bullymake is that it offers a toy-only box option, which is not available with BoxDog.

In terms of free shipping, both Bullymake and BoxDog offer it within the continental United States.

If you're not satisfied with your subscription, Bullymake has a 14-day satisfaction guarantee, whereas BoxDog does not offer a satisfaction guarantee.

Here's a comparison of the two companies' subscription plans:

BarkBox Super Chewer is a subscription box that ships immediately, with all following boxes shipping on the 15th of every month. Each box includes 2 tough toys and 2 full-sized bags of treats made in the USA or Canada.

The box has fun themes like Barkbuster Movie Night and Give N’ Thanks, which can keep your dog engaged and excited. If a toy isn't tough enough for your super chewer, BarkBox will replace it for free, no questions asked.

BarkBox offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee, which means they'll replace any toy that doesn't meet your expectations. They also cater to allergies, allowing you to exclude beef, chicken, and turkey from your box.

Their website is easy to navigate, with a good FAQ section, blog, and customer service features. You can even get a toy-only option, but you'll need to contact customer service to arrange it.

Here are the pricing plans for BarkBox Super Chewer:

Their customer service is also top-notch, standing by their 100% happiness guarantee and replacing toys without requiring photo evidence.

Customer Experience is a top priority for pet owners, and both BarkBox and Super Chewer deliver. Super Chewer's customer service is superior, according to Hank's review.

Super Chewer's fun themes and designs are a hit with pets, and their extra treat is a nice touch. They cater to pets with strong jaws, like Hank, who can't resist their tough toys.

Super Chewer's customer service is one of its standout features, making it a top choice for pet owners who value a positive experience.