Border Collies and Australian Shepherds: A Comprehensive Guide to Owning a Herding Breed

If you're considering bringing a herding breed into your family, you're probably thinking about Border Collies and Australian Shepherds. These two breeds are often compared, but they have distinct characteristics.

Border Collies are known for their high energy levels, requiring at least 1-2 hours of exercise per day to prevent boredom and destructive behavior. They excel in agility and obedience training, making them a great fit for active families.

Australian Shepherds are also high-energy dogs, but they're generally more adaptable to apartment living due to their calm nature compared to Border Collies. They require regular exercise, but they're also happy to spend time relaxing with their owners.

Both breeds are highly intelligent and thrive on mental stimulation, making them a great fit for families who enjoy interactive games and activities with their dogs.

The Border Collie and Australian Shepherd have some fascinating origins.

The Border Collie's lineage includes Viking and Roman ancestor breeds that hail from the Scottish highlands.

This breed was originally bred for herding, but they're also celebrated for their ability to perform tricks and amazing feats of agility.

The Australian Shepherd, despite its name, is not from Australia, but rather from the mountains of Europe.

It was dubbed an Australian Shepherd because its ancestors were Basque sheepherders who practiced their trade in Australia and then immigrated to America.

The Border Collie can run up to 30 mph, making them a blur when they're in motion.

Both breeds have a rich history, with the Border Collie's ancestors dating back to Britain, where they were used to help guard and herd sheep.

The Australian Shepherd's ancestors were likely imported from Australia during the 1840s, leading to their "Australian" name.

The Border Collie was recognized by the American Kennel Club on October 1, 1995, while the Australian Shepherd was recognized in 1993.

Border collies and Australian shepherds may look similar, but they have some key physical differences. The border collie is a bit leaner and more compact than the Australian shepherd, who has a hardy muscular physique.

The height of both breeds is roughly the same, with most border collies and Australian shepherds standing between 18 and 23 inches tall. However, they can differ in weight by as much as 15 pounds, with the Australian shepherd often being heavier.

Both breeds have luxurious coats that require regular brushing, with the border collie needing to be brushed 2-3 times a week and the Australian shepherd getting by with once a week. This is because both breeds have double coats to withstand the elements.

Border collies have rich cocoa-colored eyes, while Australian shepherds have eyes that can be blue, brown, or a combination of both. Some Australian shepherds even have marbled eyes.

Here's a quick comparison of the breeds' physical characteristics:

Both Border Collies and Australian Shepherds are generally healthy breeds with a lifespan of 12-15 years.

Active lifestyles, including at least 60 minutes of daily exercise and mental stimulation, can help prevent health issues.

Hip dysplasia is a common joint problem that can affect both breeds, so regular exercise and a healthy weight are crucial.

Hearing and eye problems are also potential issues to watch out for, as they can be inherited.

Australian Shepherds may be more prone to developing cancer, but responsible breeding practices can minimize this risk.

Daily exercise is essential for a Border-Aussie's well-being, with at least 40-60 minutes of walking or playtime recommended.

A backyard is a must-have for this high-energy breed, as they need space to run around and play.

Ideally, this breed will have a "job" to do, such as herding or agility practice, to keep them mentally stimulated.

Border collies and Australian shepherds are known for their intelligence and trainability. Both breeds have a high level of working intelligence, according to Professor Stanley Coren, which makes them highly trainable.

They have a unique ability called adaptive intelligence, which allows them to use their minds for problem-solving and adjusting to their environment. This means they can learn to do new things when instructed by humans.

These breeds are often described as "overachievers" and can learn a wide range of activities, from talking to practicing yoga. They're eager to be involved in whatever their humans enjoy, whether it's dog sports or advanced skill training.

In fact, border collies are relatively simple to train due to their high intelligence, and they rank among the top most intelligent breeds.

Border collies and Australian shepherds are often considered overachievers when it comes to intelligence. These herding breeds have a unique ability to think on their feet and solve problems.

They possess a high level of working intelligence, as researched by professor Stanley Coren. This means they can learn to do a wide range of tasks when instructed by humans.

Both breeds have a hard time sitting still, and need a lot of mental and physical stimulation consistently. If they don't get enough exercise, they'll get into trouble.

Border collies and Aussies are eager to be involved in whatever their humans enjoy. Whether it's paddle boarding, camping, or dog sports, they'll happily join in.

Suggestion: When Is the Best Time to Breed a Female Dog

Both Border Collies and Australian Shepherds are highly trainable due to their high intelligence, ranking among the top most intelligent breeds. They have a strong herding instinct that can make herding work a snap to train.

Their ability to learn and adapt quickly is a testament to their working intelligence, which is based on what they can learn to do when instructed by humans. This means they can pick up commands and tasks with ease.

However, training a Border Collie or Australian Shepherd requires consistent mental and physical stimulation to prevent boredom and destructive behavior. Without enough exercise and mental stimulation, they'll get into trouble.

Their independent nature can sometimes make them distracted, especially by smaller animals they feel the need to herd. This can be challenging for owners, but with patience and positive reinforcement, they can learn to focus.

A fresh viewpoint: Black and White Herding Dog

Border Collies are considered 'gathering dogs', bringing the herd together, whereas Australian Shepherds are more of a driving dog, helping move animals from place to place. This difference in herding style is due to their unique communication methods - Border Collies use a lot of eye contact and silent movements, while Australian Shepherds communicate by movement and less eye contact.

Border Collies need at least 2 hours of exercise every day to be happy and cooperative, which can include activities like jogging, biking, and hiking. They excel at sports and games they're trained to do, such as agility trials and obedience training.

A herding dog's strong desire to herd can sometimes be misinterpreted as aggressive behavior, but it's actually a natural instinct. To channel this energy in a positive way, you can engage your dog in activities like running, dog sports, or even herding toys and balls.

A Border Collie is considered a 'gathering dog', bringing the herd together with a communication style that involves a lot of eye contact, even using a silent 'slinking' to put them into position.

Australian Shepherds, on the other hand, are more of a driving dog, or drover, helping move animals from place to place.

They communicate by movement, with less eye contact, but flanking alongside or behind livestock to put them into position.

A Border Collie will rarely bark to get her point across, while an Australian Shepherd might bark to encourage a response from the herd.

Here's a quick comparison of the two breeds' herding styles:

Understanding these differences can help you appreciate the unique characteristics of each breed and find the right fit for your family.

Border Collies need at least 2 hours of exercise every day to be happy and cooperative. This can include activities like jogging, biking, and hiking.

They excel at sports and games they're trained to do, making them a great fit for agility trials and obedience training. Their high energy levels make them well-suited for activities like dock diving and cani-cross.

A Border Collie's exercise program should include more than just a walk or two around the block. They require regular physical and mental stimulation to prevent boredom and destructive behavior.

If you're thinking of bringing home a Border Collie or an Australian Shepherd, you'll want to consider your lifestyle carefully. Both breeds require a lot of exercise and mental stimulation.

You'll need wide, open spaces for your dog to run around and get some exercise. This is especially important for Border Collies, who can become destructive and anxious if they don't get enough physical activity.

A well-trained dog is a happy dog, and both Border Collies and Australian Shepherds respond well to positive reinforcement training. You'll need to be committed to training your dog regularly to keep them engaged and happy.

Here are some key factors to consider when deciding which breed is right for you:

Border Collies and Australian Shepherds are both intelligent and energetic breeds that make great companions. They are known for their high energy levels and strong herding instincts.

Origin-wise, Border Collies originated in the United States, while Australian Shepherds originated in Australia. However, the Border-Aussie, a mix of the two breeds, also has its roots in the United States.

A Border-Aussie typically stands between 17-22 inches tall at the shoulder and weighs between 30-55 pounds. Size can vary depending on the parent breeds.

Their lifespan is around 12-15 years, which is a decent amount of time to enjoy their company. They have a double coat that requires regular brushing, especially during shedding seasons.

Border Collies and Australian Shepherds are both known for their intelligence and trainability. Early socialization and positive reinforcement are crucial for managing their herding instincts and vocal tendencies.

Here's a quick rundown of their exercise needs:

Regular grooming is also a must to keep their coats healthy and mat-free. They can be prone to health issues like elbow and hip dysplasia, hearing problems, and cataracts.

Border-Aussies are often referred to as Australian Collies or Aussie Ollies, and they can be traced back to one original stud, Old Hemp. Some Australian Shepherds are born with naturally bobbed tails, so your Border-Aussie may have one too.

Border Collies and Australian Shepherds are known for their loyal nature, bonding closely with their owners. They're good with children, but may become nippy and poorly behaved without enough exercise.

These breeds are highly energetic and trainable, excelling in canine sports. They have a strong herding instinct bred into them, so helping appease this instinct through games and activities will maintain their social and loving nature.

With proper socialization from a young age, Border Collies and Australian Shepherds can become confident and calm around strangers. However, they may still be wary of unfamiliar people, including visitors.

They're naturally protective of smaller animals, but with proper introductions, they can get along just fine with cats and smaller pets. This breed is overall easygoing with almost everyone in the home, but may try to herd young children by nipping at their heels, so older kids may be the best fit.

Grooming is a crucial part of caring for your Border Collie or Australian Shepherd. Their thick coats require regular maintenance to prevent mats and tangles.

You'll need to brush your dog at least three times a week, but more often when they blow their coats. Brushing regularly will also help with shedding, especially during spring and fall when their coat changes.

A good bath is also essential, but be careful not to over-bathe, as this can upset their sensitive skin. Keep coat wipes on hand for when your dog gets dirty but doesn't need a full bath.

If you're up for it, you can groom your dog at home, but if not, schedule regular appointments with a professional groomer every 4–6 weeks.

Owning herding breeds can be a unique experience, especially if you're new to owning dogs with strong herding instincts. Herding breeds like Border Collies and Australian Shepherds were bred for farm work and dealing with livestock.

Their herding behavior can be unusual and confusing for some owners, as they may nip at the heels of whatever they're herding, including people, pets, and even trash. This behavior is a natural part of their heritage, but it's not ideal for everyday life.

If your dog is trained to perform a herding task, it's essential to train them to restrict their herding behavior to that specific job and nothing else. If your dog is just a family pet without a herding job, you might need to get creative in helping them burn off their strong desire to herd.

Some owners provide other outlets for their dog's energy, like running and doing dog sports, while others try to come up with things for their dog to herd, such as toys and balls.

Broaden your view: Are German Shepherds Good for First Time Owners