Female Dog Aggression After Spaying: Understanding the Risks and Benefits

Spaying a female dog can be a lifesaving decision, but it's not a guarantee against aggression. Some studies suggest that up to 20% of spayed female dogs may exhibit aggression towards people or other animals.

The exact reasons for this are still unclear, but research suggests that it may be linked to hormonal changes during the spaying process. One study found that the removal of the ovaries can lead to a decrease in serotonin levels, which can contribute to aggression.

In some cases, the aggression may be a result of the dog's individual personality or breed characteristics. For example, dogs with high energy levels or strong prey drive may be more prone to aggression even after spaying.

Expand your knowledge: Dog Names Female Start with S

Spaying your female dog can significantly reduce unwanted behaviors associated with the heat cycle, such as roaming, excessive urination, and bloody discharge.

Spaying before your dog reaches sexual maturity, typically between 6 to 12 months of age, is ideal as it can prevent these behaviors from developing in the first place.

Recommended read: Signs Female Dog Is Going into Heat

Spaying your dog won't affect her friendliness, working abilities, or personality, but it can reduce aggression towards dogs and humans.

Some females may show less aggression towards other pets or people after being spayed, especially if they were previously experiencing hormonally driven defensive behavior.

Spaying can also eliminate the chances of false pregnancy, a condition where females "adopt" objects and treat them like their puppies.

Here are some behavioral changes you may see in your female dog after spaying:

• Reduced roaming

• Eliminated bloody discharge

• Reduced urination

• More consistent behavior

• Reduced aggression towards dogs and humans

It's essential to note that spaying too early, especially during a phantom pregnancy, can lead to behavioral problems such as aggression, anxiety, depression, and physical problems.

A unique perspective: Maltese Dogs Behavior Problems

If your female dog is spayed during a phantom pregnancy, it can lead to some serious behavioral problems. These can include aggression, anxiety, depression, physical problems, and resource guarding.

Aggression is a big concern, especially towards other females. In fact, spaying during a phantom pregnancy can cause your dog to show aggression for weeks and even years after the surgery.

Take a look at this: Female Dog Pregnancy Stages

Anxiety and depression are also common issues that can arise from spaying during a phantom pregnancy. These emotions can be overwhelming for your dog and may require professional help from a dog behaviorist.

Spaying your dog too early can also lead to physical problems. If you don't wait for the phantom pregnancy to end before spaying, your dog may experience physical issues that can be painful and uncomfortable.

If you suspect that your female dog has been spayed during a phantom pregnancy and is now exhibiting behavioral problems, it's essential to consult with a dog behaviorist. They can provide the necessary guidance and treatment to help your dog overcome these issues.

Here are some potential behavioral problems that can arise from spaying during a phantom pregnancy:

Scientists use the word "significantly" to mean that the odds of a result happening by chance alone are less than 1 in 20, not that the effect is large or important.

A study by O'Farrell & Peachey in 1990 reported a significantly increased risk of aggression in neutered female dogs, but it had two major flaws. The risk was greatest in puppies under one year already showing some aggression, making the causal link questionable.

The study also had unequal groups being compared, which could have increased aggression in the spayed group due to pre-existing factors.

Some studies have shown a higher rate of aggression in desexed female dogs, but it's essential to examine the results critically. For example, a study might show more neutered females than intact females for a particular problem, but this is meaningless without knowing if this differs from the percent of neutered females in the population at large.

A recent scientific review article on aggression and neutering found that desexed dogs were associated with a reduced risk of dog bite, possibly in favour of reducing the risk of serious bite. However, the review also noted that there is insufficient evidence to say either way whether desexing females actually decreases aggression more than it does in males.

Check this out: Do Goldendoodles Bite

There's evidence suggesting that spaying a dog can lead to aggression, but it's not as simple as it seems. The word "significantly" in scientific studies means the odds of the result happening by chance alone are less than 1 in 20, not that the effect is large or important.

O'Farrell & Peachey's 1990 study found a significantly increased risk of aggression in neutered female dogs, but it had two major flaws. The study compared puppies under one year already showing aggression, making the causal link questionable.

The study also had unequal groups being compared, which could have increased aggression in the spayed group. This is especially true for rescue dogs acquired at an older age.

Spaying won't improve negative behavior in dogs, and it may even make things worse. This is especially true for dogs that are highly reactive, acting male, or showing confident aggression.

Spaying can also increase aggression in dogs that live with other females, especially if they're similar in age or breed. The higher hormone levels during a season can increase aggression, and spaying may stop these hormone flares.

You might enjoy: How to Tell the Age of a Female Dog

Here are some potential behavioral problems caused by spaying at the wrong time:

It's essential to wait for a dog's phantom pregnancy to end before spaying, as interrupting her hormonal flow can lead to these behavioral problems. If your dog has already been spayed during a phantom pregnancy, a dog behaviorist can help treat her with medication, which can be given up to three years after spaying and still take full effect.

You might like: Female Dog Phantom Pregnancy

Research suggests that spaying your female dog can actually decrease aggression, but the evidence is still limited and not entirely clear.

Spayed dogs are associated with a reduced risk of dog bites, possibly even a significant reduction in serious bites.

However, the data available doesn't allow for a detailed examination of the effects on male and female dogs, and it's possible that desexing females may decrease aggression more than it does in males.

Despite many studies, there's only limited evidence to support the idea that spaying affects aggression in female dogs, and other factors like puppy socialization and training are likely to be much more important.

Spaying your dog won't affect her friendliness, working abilities, or personality, but it can affect behaviors associated with her heat cycle.

Some of these behaviors include roaming, excessive urination, and hormonal changes that can lead to irritability or anxiety.

Spaying can also eliminate the chances of hormonally driven defensive behavior, which may include aggression towards dogs and humans.

Discover more: Does Spaying a Female Dog Affect Her Growth

Spaying can have a significant impact on a female dog's behavior, and it's essential to consider this before making a decision. Generally, spaying won't improve negative behavior, and it may even make things worse in some cases.

For example, if a female dog is already highly reactive, spaying may not be the solution. In fact, it's recommended to address behavior modification first, especially if she's fearful or under-confident.

Some dogs, like larger breeds or those prone to joint problems, may benefit from having at least one season before being spayed. This allows their joints to grow properly and their vulva to develop better.

However, spaying may be recommended if a female dog shows increased reactivity and aggression only around the time of her season. In these cases, spaying may help reduce hormone flares that can contribute to aggression.

It's also worth noting that some studies have reported a higher rate of aggression in desexed female dogs, but these findings are not always reliable. For instance, a 1990 study found a significantly increased risk of aggression in neutered female dogs, but the study had some significant flaws.

In some cases, spaying can even lead to new behavioral problems, such as aggression or withdrawal. For example, a beagle owner reported that her dog became more intense around food and started growling at other dogs after being spayed.

Here are some key considerations to keep in mind:

There are three options for spaying your dog: taking away the ovaries but leaving the uterus, taking away the uterus but leaving the ovaries, and doing a full ovariohysterectomy (which takes both the uterus and ovaries).

Suggestion: Dog Bites Fingers When Taking Treats

Before making a decision, it's essential to consider your dog's individual needs and your home environment. Here are some factors to think about:

The cost to spay your dog varies based on their breed and your individual vet. For example, dog spaying costs at some vet practices start from £244.