Just Food for Dogs vs Farmer's Dog: A Comprehensive Comparison

Just Food for Dogs and Farmer's Dog are two popular dog food brands that have gained a loyal following among pet owners. Just Food for Dogs is a subscription-based service that offers customized, human-grade dog food made from fresh ingredients.

Their food is prepared in small batches and tailored to each dog's individual needs, with options for grain-free, gluten-free, and limited-ingredient diets. This flexibility is a major draw for pet owners who want to ensure their dogs receive the best possible nutrition.

Farmer's Dog, on the other hand, offers a more streamlined approach with a focus on simplicity and sustainability. Their food is made from high-quality, locally sourced ingredients and is designed to be easy to digest.

The Farmer's Dog has a cleaner recall history compared to Just Food For Dogs.

In 2018, Just Food For Dogs issued a voluntary recall of three of their diets due to the risk of potential Listeria contamination on green beans.

The Farmer's Dog, on the other hand, has had no recalls to date. This is a significant difference in their safety records.

Just Food For Dogs is the clear winner for us because they employ board-certified veterinary nutritionists to formulate their recipes.

These experts tailor their recipes to meet specific dietary needs, including those of dogs on prescription diets.

They also run feeding trials to ensure their foods are palatable and produce health-centered results in dogs.

Their commitment to quality and safety is evident in their rigorous testing process.

By offering consultations to help guide you in selecting the right recipes, they provide a personalized approach to pet nutrition.

Just Food For Dogs has had a recall history, with a voluntary recall issued in 2018. They recalled three of their diets due to the risk of potential Listeria contamination on the green beans.

The recalled diets were Turducken, Fish & Sweet Potato, and Beef & Russet Potato, manufactured between November 1, 2017 and January 14, 2018.

Just Food For Dogs offers a better nutritional value than The Farmer’s Dog, primarily because their recipes are formulated by veterinarians and reviewed by multiple veterinarians.

Both The Farmer’s Dog and JustFoodForDogs use all-natural, limited ingredients that are 100% USDA-certified for human consumption.

All recipes from both brands are formulated by veterinary nutritionists and cooked in USDA-certified and inspected kitchens.

The Farmer’s Dog adds fresh vegetables, salmon oil, and essential vitamins and minerals to all four recipes, while JustFoodForDogs takes a similar healthy approach to their meals with high-quality animal protein as the first ingredient.

Every meal from The Farmer’s Dog contains only a single protein, and their chicken and beef recipes also contain organ meat.

JustFoodForDogs offers custom meals that meet a specific dog’s needs or that can help support a health condition, and they even have options for large-breed dogs.

Both brands offer superior nutritional value, exceeding AAFCO standards and using whole food, human-grade ingredients approved by the USDA for human consumption.

They both also use ingredients that are free from fillers and preservatives, making them excellent choices for picky eaters.

JustFoodForDogs can make custom meals that meet a specific dog’s needs or that can help support a health condition, each developed to ensure all types of dogs can get a complete and balanced meal with quality nutritional support.

Both The Farmer's Dog and JustFoodForDogs offer competitive pricing, with The Farmer's Dog starting at $2 per day and JustFoodForDogs starting at around $1.36 per day. However, prices vary based on your dog's size and meal preferences.

The Farmer's Dog requires a subscription, which you can cancel anytime, and all shipping is free. In contrast, JustFoodForDogs gives you the option of making a one-time purchase or signing up for auto-shipping, which saves you 5% off recurring orders and gives you free shipping.

To get the best pricing comparison, it's essential to run quotes for your dog, as prices differ between the two companies. For a two-year-old mixed-breed dog at an ideal weight and normal activity level, JustFoodForDogs was cheaper for a 10-pound dog ($19.39/week) but more expensive for a 60-pound dog ($59.50/week), compared to The Farmer's Dog.

Here's a comparison of the prices for a 10, 40, and 60-pound dog, based on the chicken recipe:

JustFoodForDogs also offers DIY supplement kits for pet parents who want to save extra money without compromising on the quality of their dog's food. Each kit comes with a nutrient blend, shopping list, and recipe instructions to ensure dog parents are making nutritionally balanced meals at home.

We've had our fair share of experiences with both Just Food For Dogs and Farmer's Dog, and we've learned a thing or two about what makes them tick.

Just Food For Dogs' pre-made meals are made with high-quality protein sources like chicken and salmon, which are rich in essential amino acids.

One of the biggest differences we've noticed is the customization options with Farmer's Dog, which allows you to tailor your dog's diet to their individual needs and preferences.

Farmer's Dog's recipes are made with fresh, whole ingredients that are sourced from local farms and suppliers whenever possible.

Our experience with The Farmer's Dog has been overwhelmingly positive. Our team members' dogs have seen significant improvements in their health since switching to The Farmer's Dog. Lexie, one team member's dog, has had much more consistent bowel movements and has maintained a healthier weight since switching from kibble.

The Farmer's Dog's food is easy to digest and has even improved the shine and health of Lexie's coat. We've been impressed with the results and would recommend The Farmer's Dog to anyone looking for a healthy option for their pup.

When looking at the ingredients and options of various dog food companies, I was impressed by the variety offered by JustFoodForDogs. They have nearly a dozen recipes, including grain-free and grain-inclusive options, as well as meals featuring novel proteins like lamb and venison.

One thing that sets JustFoodForDogs apart is their ability to create customized diets for pets with specific needs. If none of their available options work for your pet, you can work with an on-staff veterinarian and Nutrition Consultant to develop a meal plan that meets their dietary requirements.

The Farmer's Dog, on the other hand, has a more limited selection of four grain-free recipes. They also offer human-grade ingredients and are formulated to AAFCO standards.

Here's a comparison of the ingredient options for JustFoodForDogs and The Farmer's Dog:

I was also impressed by the variety of recipes offered by JustFoodForDogs, including options for joint and skin support, large breed support, and renal support.

The Farmer's Dog packs are multi-serving, making them a great option for pet owners with multiple pets or those who want to plan ahead.

We found their shape, with thin flat sleeves, to be much easier to stack and store in the refrigerator or freezer.

The quantity of packaging in each shipment is a drawback, but it's all recyclable.

When it comes to the ingredients and options of these two dog food brands, there are some notable differences.

Both PetPlate and The Farmer's Dog do not use preservatives in their formulas. This is a great option for pet owners who prefer to avoid artificial additives in their dog's food.

PetPlate offers a wider range of flavor options, including Chicken, Turkey, Beef, and Lamb. The Farmer's Dog, on the other hand, offers Turkey, Beef, and Pork.

Here's a comparison of the two brands' ingredients:

Both PetPlate and The Farmer's Dog use human-grade ingredients and are formulated to meet AAFCO standards. This ensures that the food meets the nutritional needs of dogs.

The Farmer’s Dog takes customization to the next level with their online dog profile that asks for your pup’s breed, gender, age, activity level, current weight, and body condition. This helps them tailor meals and portions to your dog’s specific needs.

Their questionnaire also allows you to indicate any health issues your furry friend may have, such as allergies, gluten or grain insensitivity, ear infections, digestive issues, arthritis, and more. This ensures the food they provide is not only nutritious but also safe for your dog to eat.

JustFoodForDogs offers a feeding calculator on their website to help you figure out how much food to buy and how much to feed your dog each day based on his age, weight, and activity level. However, this is a one-size-fits-all solution, lacking the personal touch that The Farmer’s Dog provides.

The Farmer’s Dog’s customized meals come at a $250 formulation fee, but it’s worth it for the peace of mind that comes with knowing your dog is getting exactly what they need.

When choosing a pet food, the ingredients are a crucial aspect to consider. The quality of ingredients can greatly impact your pet's health and well-being.

Let's take a look at what's in some popular pet food options. Both PetPlate and The Farmer's Dog offer a range of flavors, including chicken, turkey, beef, and lamb.

PetPlate offers four flavor options: chicken, turkey, beef, and lamb. The Farmer's Dog also offers a variety of flavors, with turkey and beef being two of the options available.

If you're concerned about preservatives in your pet's food, you'll be happy to know that both PetPlate and The Farmer's Dog are free from preservatives.

Both PetPlate and The Farmer's Dog use human-grade ingredients, ensuring that your pet is getting the best possible nutrition. This is a significant advantage over lower-quality pet foods that may contain fillers or by-products.

Both PetPlate and The Farmer's Dog are formulated to meet the AAFCO standards, giving you peace of mind that your pet is getting the nutrients they need.

Here's a comparison of the ingredients from both PetPlate and The Farmer's Dog:

By choosing a pet food that meets these standards, you can trust that you're giving your pet the best possible chance at a healthy and happy life.

JustFoodForDogs has a much wider selection of food than Farmer's Dog. They offer nearly a dozen recipes, including grain-free and grain-inclusive options.

Their menu features novel proteins like lamb and venison, which is a great option for pets with specific dietary needs. You can also choose from high-protein and healthy veggie options.

JustFoodForDogs offers veterinary-prescribed food options for various health issues, including renal support, hepatic support, and metabolic support. This is a huge plus for pet parents who need customized diets for their pets.

One of the standout features of JustFoodForDogs is their ability to create a customized diet formulated especially for your pet. If none of their available options work for your pet, you can work with an on-staff veterinarian and Nutrition Consultant to develop a meal plan.

Here are the recipe options available from JustFoodForDogs:

JustFoodForDogs has an average rating of 4.5 stars out of 5 based on nearly 200 reviews on Yelp.

Many customers have reported a significant improvement in their dogs' health and happiness after switching to JustFoodForDogs. One customer mentioned that their dog, Lucy, loves every flavor they've tried and gives them pleasure to see her lick the bowl clean.

The Farmer's Dog, on the other hand, has an average review of 4.7 stars based on over 1,000 reviews on Trustpilot. Customers have praised the company's customer service, with one reviewer mentioning that their experience was "amazing" and that the team "really care about customers and the health of dogs!"

Some customers have reported that their dogs have become more lively, energetic, and healthy since switching to The Farmer's Dog. One reviewer credited the company's food with giving them an additional four years with their dog, stating "The Farmer's Dog is the reason we had an additional four years with her."