Lychee and Dog Meat Festival: Unpacking the Controversy Surrounding China's Yulin Festival

The Lychee and Dog Meat Festival in China's Yulin city has been a topic of heated debate for years. This annual festival has sparked outrage and concern among animal lovers and activists worldwide.

The festival, which typically takes place in June, is said to have originated from a local tradition of consuming dog meat as a way to ward off the summer heat. It's a notion that has been widely disputed, with many arguing that there's no scientific basis for this claim.

Activists and animal welfare organizations have been vocal in their opposition to the festival, citing concerns about animal cruelty and the inhumane treatment of dogs. Many have also questioned the festival's connection to the lychee fruit, which is often associated with the event but not directly involved in its practices.

The festival's organizers claim that the event is a cultural tradition that should be respected, but critics argue that it's nothing more than a cruel and outdated practice that has no place in modern society.

You might enjoy: Animal Cropping

The number of dogs slaughtered and eaten during the Yulin festival has changed over the years, with the largest reported number being over 10,000.

Dog meat is a traditional food in some areas of southern China, where it is believed to be good for the body in warm weather.

Animal rights activists have raided slaughterhouses and intercepted truckloads of dogs in efforts to limit the number of animals killed.

The dog meat trade is inhumane and unhygienic, with dogs caught with wire lassos, transported in tiny cages, and slaughtered with metal rods.

Activists say the killing of any animal will be bloody, but many argue that popular customs like the lychee and dog meat festival cannot be right or wrong.

Humane Society International claims that the festival was "manufactured" by the dog meat traders and that dog meat is not part of mainstream food culture in China.

The number of dogs eaten during the festival has decreased in recent years, from over 10,000 to around 3,000.

You might enjoy: Dogs in Ancient China

The Yulin Festival has been a lightning rod for controversy since its inception. It was initially promoted by dog-meat traders and restaurants in conjunction with the local government as a tourism initiative.

The festival has been met with immediate outcry from both domestic and international communities, with millions of people signing petitions to ban the slaughtering of dogs for meat. Critics claim that the animals are treated in cruel and inhumane ways.

Around 10,000 dogs are killed during the festival, with some being kept in cramped and unhygienic cages and transported over long distances without food or water. Photographs from the event show dogs wearing collars, suggesting they might be stolen pets.

The festival's defenders claim that dog consumption is part of Chinese culture, but others rebut that the vast majority of Chinese people do not eat dog meat.

The consequences of eating dog meat are far-reaching and disturbing. Nearly 75% of Yulin residents had not ever eaten dog meat, despite the efforts of the dog-meat trade to promote it.

The dog meat trade is not only cruel to animals but also poses a risk to human health. The coronavirus pandemic in 2020, which was likely exacerbated by the trade, should have been a wake-up call for the local government.

Even one dog being slaughtered for meat is one dog too many. We believe that the number of dogs killed, although decreasing, is still unacceptable.

The fact that the Yulin festival still happened in 2020, despite the decree declaring dogs as companion animals not livestock, is a testament to the power of local traders.

See what others are reading: Rescue Dogs from China Meat Trade

The festival is surrounded by controversy, with estimates suggesting that around 10,000 dogs are killed during the event.

Critics claim that the animals are treated cruelly and inhumanely, including being kept in cramped and unhygienic cages.

Photographs taken by activists show some dogs wearing collars, suggesting they might be stolen pets.

Defenders of the festival argue that dog consumption is a part of Chinese culture, no different from slaughtering cows or chickens for meat.

However, others point out that the vast majority of Chinese people do not eat dog meat, and the festival has no cultural or traditional value, existing primarily for commercial gain.

Millions of people from China and abroad have signed petitions to ban the slaughtering of dogs for meat.

Recommended read: Best Food for Dogs with No Teeth

The Yulin government has made a statement distancing themselves from the festival, clarifying that it's not an official holiday but rather an unofficial event held by a small portion of the city's inhabitants.

The government's statement was published in Xinhua, a Chinese news agency, and it explicitly stated that the Yulin government respects the concerns of netizens and organizations regarding the festival.

The Yulin government advocates for a "healthy food culture" and "concern for and protection of animals", which suggests that they are at least paying lip service to the concerns of those who oppose the festival.

However, it's worth noting that the government's statement does not explicitly condemn the festival or call for its cancellation.