It's frustrating to see your dog still scratching away despite having a flea collar. The truth is, flea collars are not a foolproof solution to flea infestations.
Flea collars can be effective in killing adult fleas, but they may not prevent eggs from hatching and new fleas from emerging.
Some flea collars contain ingredients like imidacloprid, which can kill fleas within 24 hours, but this can vary depending on the product and the dog's individual sensitivity.
It's not uncommon for dogs to still have fleas despite wearing a flea collar, especially if the infestation is severe or the collar is not used correctly.
Consider reading: Dog Flea Treatment Not Working
Treatment Effectiveness
It's not uncommon for a flea problem to seem worse before it gets better, and this could be related to numbers of new adults hatching out. It's normal for it to take at least two weeks before there's much improvement, and often, it takes even longer than that.
The flea collar you're using might be killing adult fleas when they suck blood, but there could still be thousands of fleas emerging to feed. Most products don't kill fleas instantaneously.
Treating all your pets and your home will kill off the adults, the larvae, and the eggs, however, the surviving pupae will still go on and hatch as adults. The eggs should die once in contact with the treated environment.
If you're still seeing adult fleas, or you're being bitten, don't panic! It's likely that the flea problem will improve over time, but it might take a bit longer than you expect.
Flea product characteristics, such as how they target different stages of the flea life cycle, can affect their success in some situations.
Check this out: Does Salt Water Kill Fleas on Dogs
Flea Collar Issues
Some flea collars may not be ideal for areas with high concentrations of fleas and ticks.
Flea collars can take time to spread throughout your pet's skin and coat, which may not be effective for current flea infestations.
The medication in flea collars may not be safe if your pet comes into regular contact with other animals or children.
Children could easily play with your pet's collar and touch their eyes or face, which is a risk to consider.
Flea collars are also not ideal for dogs with known flea allergies.
Flea collars only kill fleas currently living on your pet, not fleas that may be living in the environment.
Collars may not be effective in areas where fleas live year-round.
Alternative Solutions
If you've already tried a flea collar and still have fleas, it's time to consider alternative solutions.
Flea spot on treatments are another option available, which can be applied directly to your dog's skin.
You might need to try a different type of product if the one you're using isn't working, so it's worth exploring other options.
Flea product characteristics, such as the type of active ingredient, can affect their success in certain situations.
Flea collars and spot on treatments aren't the only options available, and it's worth considering other types of products.
Flea Collar Function
Flea collars are not created equal, and some only repel fleas and ticks, while others actually kill them.
If a flea collar merely repels insects, it may offer some protection, but it's not ideal for areas with high concentrations of fleas and ticks.
The label on a high-quality flea collar should specifically say it kills fleas, flea eggs, and ticks.
Flea collars that kill fleas on contact, before they can bite your pet, are the most effective.
Broaden your view: Can a Flea Kill a Dog
Sprays and Other Options
If your dog still has fleas despite wearing a flea collar, it might be worth considering other options. Alongside flea collars and spot on treatments, there are other options available too.
Flea spray is a good alternative to consider, as it can act like a good flea shampoo and kill adult fleas. It should be used in conjunction with one of the other dog flea treatment types to ensure further prevention and reduction in flea larvae.
Tick Collars vs. Drops
Tick collars have been around for a long time, and they can be very effective in tackling ticks.
Flea and tick drops are a standard practice for many dog owners, but they're not the only option. The article notes that both treatments can be very effective.
Some dog owners swear by flea collars, but it's essential to consider the needs of both you and your pet when making a decision.
Spray
A good dog flea spray will act like a good flea shampoo and kill the adult fleas. It should be used in conjunction with one of the other dog flea treatment types.
You can use flea spray in conjunction with flea collars or spot on treatments for further prevention and reduction in flea larvae.
Here's an interesting read: Dog Flea Spray Diy
Resistance and Failure
Flea treatment failure is a common reason people think their treatment isn't working or that they must have a resistant flea population. If you don't kill the developing fleas, you won't prevent fleas emerging to bite you and your pets.
Treating your pets and not the environment can work as a preventative if you don't have an established flea population in your home, but it's not enough if you already have a problem. This is a common reason for people thinking their flea treatment isn't working.
Some flea products only kill adult fleas, while others can prevent their eggs from developing, and yet others can affect all stages of development other than pupae. This means that even if your dog's flea collar is killing adult fleas, it may not be preventing new fleas from emerging.
The product's action persistence is also important - some products should be used monthly, others every three, six or 12 months, and there are even products that only work for 24-48 hours but kill adult fleas from 30 minutes after administration. This can influence how many eggs could be produced by a female flea before she dies.
If the product is getting removed - perhaps because your dog is bathed or swims regularly, or the treated floors around your cat's bed are mopped daily - it won't be able to do its job properly.
Broaden your view: Do Dog Flea Collars Work
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take for a flea collar to get rid of fleas?
Flea collars typically start working within 24 to 48 hours, killing existing fleas and new ones that emerge. Some high-performance collars, like Seresto, can kill existing fleas in as little as 24 hours and new ones in just 2 hours.
Sources
- https://www.care.com/c/my-dog-has-fleas-what-to-do-if-your-dog-brin/
- https://www.vets4pets.com/pet-health-advice/why-isnt-my-flea-treatment-working/
- https://www.oscarandhooch.com/blog/dog-flea-collar-vs-dog-flea-drops/
- https://tevrapet.com/are-flea-collars-right-for-your-dog/
- https://www.domyown.com/seresto-dog-flea-and-tick-collar-questions-pq-14038.html
Featured Images: pexels.com