
A shock collar pet trainer can be a useful tool for teaching your dog basic obedience commands, such as "sit" and "stay", especially for dogs with strong prey drives.
The most effective shock collars can deliver a range of stimulation levels, from low to high, allowing you to tailor the training to your dog's individual needs.
Shock collars can be used to train dogs of all ages, but they're most effective for puppies between 6 and 12 months old, when they're still learning good behavior.
Consistency is key when using a shock collar, so establish a routine and stick to it to avoid confusing your dog.
What is a Shock Collar?
A shock collar is actually referred to as an e-collar by many dog trainers and owners, and it's a device that uses a remote control to deliver a warning beep or vibration followed by a shock if the dog doesn't stop bad behavior.
Shock collars are also known as dog training collars or electronic collars, and they work by associating the beep with the shock so the dog learns to stop the behavior before a shock is necessary.
The shock level can range from a tickling sensation to a more painful shock, but when used correctly, shock collars can be an effective behavior modification tool.
These collars allow you to get your dog's attention even when he's not close, and they can be especially helpful for dogs that don't respond to voice commands.
Shock collars can be used in combination with an electric fence to shut down aggressive behaviors and unwanted barking, and they're a convenient option for those who can't be there to supervise their dog all the time.
The instant feedback provided by shock collars can be helpful in suppressing undesirable behaviors, and they're often a more affordable option than hiring a professional trainer.
On a similar theme: Shock Collar Doesn T Phase Dog
Benefits and Effectiveness
Shock collars can be effective in suppressing undesirable behaviors, especially when used in combination with positive reinforcement training and socialization. This approach worked for one dog owner who used a shock collar to train their dog Teddy to stop barking in hotel rooms and behave reliably off-leash.
The shock collar allowed the owner to correct Teddy's behavior from a distance, which is a major advantage over other training methods. With a shock collar, you can get your dog's attention even when they're not close to you.
Using a shock collar can be especially helpful for dogs that don't respond to voice commands or have a tendency to run off when they see something. In Teddy's case, the owner found that the shock collar was effective in preventing her from barking in hotel rooms, even when she was off-leash.
The return on using a shock collar can be enormous, as it has allowed Teddy to live a happier and more fulfilled life with her owners.
Here's an interesting read: Training Your Dog off Leash
Why It Worked

The shock collar worked for Teddy's owners because it was a brief intervention that ensured they could bring her on a month-long trip to southern Baja and back.
They were able to achieve remarkable reliability in Teddy's behaviors, including not barking in a hotel room once, and being reliable off-leash around other guests at a fancy hotel.
The owners employed the shock collar only for two specific behaviors, and applied remarkably few shocks, even fewer than once every two weeks.
Teddy learned to associate the shock collar with not barking, and wearing it prevented her from barking altogether.
The return on the few momentary instances of pain from the shocks was enormous, as Teddy got to live a happier, more fulfilled life where she was included and trusted throughout their travel and experiences.
Expand your knowledge: Two Dog Shock Collar
Pros of Dog Training
Shock collars can be a useful tool for fixing behavioral problems from a distance, allowing you to get your dog's attention even when he's not close.
This is especially helpful for dogs who don't respond to voice commands or engage in unwanted behavior when you're not around, such as running wildly after something or barking excessively.
Using a shock collar in combination with an electric fence can shut down aggressive behaviors and give your dog instant feedback.
Another benefit of shock collars is that they don't require your presence to use, allowing you to use a remote control to give your dog a gentle shock and avoid associating you with negative feedback.
Shock collars are also an affordable training tool, costing much less than the services of a professional trainer.
Don't Knock It Till You Try It
The idea that shock collars are inhumane is a common misconception. Many people are initially turned off by the thought of using an e-collar, but it's essential to experience it firsthand to understand its effectiveness.
Shock collars can be quite gentle if set up correctly, as seen in Example 2, where the author mentions that the collar can be useful for dogs who are resistant to other methods for reducing undesirable behavior.
The e-collar is not as shocking as people think, as demonstrated in Example 4, where the author puts the collar in a person's hand and uses the remote at the lowest level, pressing the button, asking if they can feel anything. The reaction is often, "That's it?!"
The lowest level of the e-collar is often not enough to elicit a response from the dog, as seen in Example 3, where the author finds the dog's training threshold by starting at level one and working their way up until it elicits a response. The point at which the dog responds is all it needs to learn from it.
It's essential to determine the dog's sensitivity to the shock, as instructed by Garmin, to ensure the e-collar is used effectively and humanely. This involves finding the lowest level possible that elicits a response from the dog.
Curious to learn more? Check out: Conditioned Emotional Response Dog Training
Potential Drawbacks
Using a shock collar can be a bit of a double-edged sword. It's hard for most dog owners to envision causing their best friend any kind of pain, so they typically prefer positive reinforcement methods too.
One of the biggest cons to the use of aversive training is that it doesn’t address the underlying problem. This can lead to the undesirable behavior coming back once the shock collar is removed.
The potential for misuse and even abuse with e-collars is a major concern. It's not just about shocking the dog too much, but also about the risk of automatic bark collars and electric fences delivering too many shocks or even shocking your dog unintentionally.
E-collar training can suppress undesirable behavior, but it doesn't get to the root of the issue.
Alternatives and Comparison
Vibrating collars are a great option for behavior modification dog training, as they get your dog's attention with vibration instead of shock, making them suitable for deaf dogs who can't hear voice commands or a clicker.
For excessive barking, bark collars can be effective, emitting a burst of citronella or air to catch your dog's attention, or an ultrasonic sound only your dog can hear.
It's essential to note that bark collars can be triggered by another dog's bark, so it's best to use them when your dog is alone.
Dog Training System
A dog training system can be a lifesaver, especially for owners who struggle with behavioral issues. The Garmin Sport Pro training system is a popular choice, featuring a collar-mounted device with automatic bark-correction capability.
This system includes a handheld controller with a 3/4-mile range, allowing you to correct your dog's behavior remotely. The controller gives you both vibration and beep cues, as well as ten selectable levels of shock to choose from.
Some owners swear by the effectiveness of the Sport Pro, citing its ability to deliver training results almost immediately. In fact, one owner reported that the collar helped to correct their dog's aggressive behavior, which had previously led to a close call with wildlife officers.
The Sport Pro can control up to three collars, and the batteries in both the collar and handheld last up to 60 hours. This makes it a convenient option for owners who need to train multiple dogs or have a busy schedule.
On a similar theme: Sleepypod Clickit Sport Crash-tested Car Safety Dog Harness
Alternatives to Collars
You can try alternative collars that don't use shock, like vibrating collars that get your dog's attention with vibration instead of shock.
These collars are useful for deaf dogs who can't hear voice commands or a clicker, and can be just as effective as shock collars.
Bark collars are another option that emit a burst of citronella or air to catch your dog's attention, or ultrasonic sounds only your dog can hear.
However, it's best not to use bark collars when other dogs are around, as another dog's bark can trigger the collar.
Some high-pitched barks may not trigger spray collars, making them ineffective for dogs with that type of bark.
These alternatives to e-collars or prong/pinch collars are much less problematic and worth considering before resorting to shock collars.
E-Collar vs Shock Collar
The terms e-collar and shock collar are often used interchangeably, but they have a subtle difference. The term e-collar refers to an electronic collar that is controlled by a remote.
Some e-collars are specifically designed for training purposes, while others may be used as bark collars or no-bark collars that aren't controlled via remote. The term shock collar technically refers to the same thing, but it's often used in a derogatory manner.
Some trainers have tried to reclaim the term shock collar, but e-collar is still the most commonly used term.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do dog trainers recommend shock collars?
No, reputable dog trainers do not recommend shock collars due to their potential to cause fear, pain, and aggression. Instead, they advocate for positive reinforcement training methods that promote a safe and loving learning environment for dogs.
Do police dog trainers use shock collars?
Police dog trainers may use shock collars, but this method is not recommended due to potential harm to the dog's welfare. More humane training methods are preferred in modern police dog training practices.
What is the difference between an e-collar and a shock collar?
An e-collar is a general term for training collars, while a shock collar is a specific type that uses static stimulation as a corrective measure. Understanding the difference between these two is crucial for choosing the right training tool for your needs.
Are shock collars illegal for dogs?
No, shock collars are not allowed for dog training in England, as their use is banned by law as of February 2024. However, the use of shock collars may still be permitted in other countries or regions.
Sources
- https://wholesale.patpet.com/product-item/dog-training-anti-bark-collar-301/
- https://worldofdogtraining.com/electric-collar-e-collar-dog-training/
- https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-gear/tools/dog-shock-collar-training-experience/
- https://outwardhound.com/furtropolis/dogs/are-shock-collars-bad-for-dogs
- https://www.chaostocalmk9training.com/blog/2020/10/8/why-i-train-dogs-with-e-collars
Featured Images: pexels.com