Veterinary Ear Cropping: History, Purpose, and Controversy

Author

Posted Oct 20, 2024

Reads 1.3K

Pig
Credit: pexels.com, Pig

Ear cropping has been a long-standing practice in the veterinary world, with its roots dating back to ancient times. In the 18th century, European veterinarians began cropping the ears of dogs to prevent injuries and infections.

The practice was initially used to prevent dogs from getting their ears torn or caught in hunting nets. This was particularly common for breeds like the Pointer and the Spaniel.

Ear cropping has been a staple in the veterinary world for centuries, with many veterinarians continuing to perform the procedure today. However, the practice has also been met with controversy.

What Is Ear Cropping?

Ear cropping is a surgical procedure that involves removing a portion of a dog's ear to prevent injuries or infections, or to conform to breed standards. The procedure is typically performed on puppies between 7 and 14 days old.

The goal of ear cropping is to prevent ear infections, which can be painful and potentially lead to more serious health issues. Ear infections are a common problem in dogs, especially those with floppy ears.

The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) has taken a stance against ear cropping for non-therapeutic purposes, citing concerns about animal welfare and the risks associated with the procedure.

What Is Ear Cropping?

Credit: youtube.com, Dog Ear Cropping the pros and cons of Ear Cropping?

Ear cropping is a surgical procedure that involves cutting or trimming a dog's ears to a specific shape or size. This is typically done to prevent infections and reduce the risk of ear mites.

Ear cropping has been practiced for centuries, originating from ancient civilizations such as the Egyptians and Greeks. They believed that cropped ears made their dogs appear more aggressive and intimidating.

The procedure is usually performed on puppies between 6 to 12 weeks old, when they are still in the developmental stage. This is the ideal time to perform ear cropping because the ears are still soft and pliable.

The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) does not recommend ear cropping as a routine procedure, citing concerns about animal welfare.

History and Purpose

Ear cropping has its roots in ancient times, where it was performed for practical reasons such as preventing injuries while hunting or fighting.

Working dogs had their ears cropped to prevent injuries, and tails were docked to avoid infections and injuries in rough terrains.

Credit: youtube.com, Reasons for cropping dogs' ears | Tier 1 Veterinary Medical Center

These procedures were initially done to make dogs safer and healthier, but in modern times, they're often done for cosmetic purposes.

Many dog breeds are subjected to ear cropping and tail docking to meet specific breed standards set by dog show organizations.

The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) opposes ear cropping and tail docking, citing the lack of medical benefits and the potential risks and complications associated with these procedures.

Recommended read: Tail Docking Ear Cropping

Why Do People Crop Some Dogs' Ears?

People crop the ears of certain breeds of dogs to meet a cosmetic appearance, sometimes to honor or replicate a putative function. This practice has historical roots, with some breeds developed for specific tasks, such as barn ratters, having their ears cropped to minimize the risk of injury.

Some breeds, like the Miniature Pinscher and Brussels Griffon, historically had their ears cropped to mimic their original function. Today, these breeds are more commonly used as companion animals rather than barn ratters, but some breeders continue to crop the ears of these breeds to maintain the look related to their historic function.

Credit: youtube.com, Is ear cropping GOOD or BAD for your dog? Should it be banned? VOTE NOW🗳 🤏

The "bully breeds", including the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, and Staffordshire Bull Terrier, were once used for dog fighting, and their ears were severely cropped to prevent an opponent from gaining an advantage. This closely cropped look has become synonymous with toughness in some circles.

There's no evidence that ear cropping enhances a dog's hearing, despite some breeds having their ears cropped for this reason. Boxers, for example, traditionally had their ears cropped to improve their hearing for roles as working dogs, but it's more likely that removing part of the ear pinna alters how sounds are funneled into the dog's ear canal.

In the past, some dog owners cropped their dog's ears for practical reasons, such as better hunting performance or fewer ear infections. However, there's no proof that cropped ears lead to fewer ear infections.

Today, people crop their dog's ears for cosmetic reasons, wanting their dogs to have the defining features set by other dogs. Dog owners who register their dogs in shows may also crop the ears to preserve the breed and its history.

Curious to learn more? Check out: Yorkshire Terrier Ear Infection

The Procedure and Risks

Credit: youtube.com, Doberman Pinscher Ear Cropping: What's it Like?

Ear cropping is a surgical procedure that involves removing part of the ear flap, typically performed by a licensed veterinarian under general anesthesia. Puppies are usually 6 to 12 weeks old when their ears are cropped.

The surgery must be done before the cartilage acquires its shape and permanent position, which happens at around 4 months of age. This is why it's essential to have the procedure done by a veterinarian with experience in ear cropping.

The risks of ear cropping include infections, scarring, and distorted ear shapes if not done correctly. The process can also cause significant discomfort for the dog, both during the surgery and throughout the healing period.

How It Works

Ear cropping is a surgical procedure that involves removing part of the ear flap, typically done by a licensed veterinarian with experience in this procedure.

The surgery is usually performed under general anesthesia and must be done before the cartilage acquires its shape and permanent position, which happens around 4 months of age.

Veterinarian Checking the Ear of a Dog Using Surgical Scissors
Credit: pexels.com, Veterinarian Checking the Ear of a Dog Using Surgical Scissors

Puppies are typically between 6 and 12 weeks old when their ears are cropped, and the procedure involves removing cartilage and skin, cutting through blood vessels and nerve endings, and suturing the final wounds.

The ears must be taped to a hard surface to heal in an upright position, and bandages need to be changed weekly, typically, for the entire process which can last from 4-8 weeks.

The surgery has no veterinary medical purpose, and it's an elective cosmetic surgery that requires special care post-surgery to achieve the most successful outcome.

With proper care, the ears can heal in the desired upright precision, and a successful outcome is possible, as demonstrated by some veterinarians who have achieved a 99% success rate of both ears standing properly.

Risks and Complications

Ear cropping is a surgical procedure that can lead to infections, scarring, and distorted ear shapes if not done correctly. This can result in significant discomfort for the dog during the surgery and throughout the healing period.

A Veterinarian Sitting Beside a Black Dog Lying on the Table
Credit: pexels.com, A Veterinarian Sitting Beside a Black Dog Lying on the Table

The process is painful, and long-term effects can include phantom pain, increased sensitivity to cold or wind, and difficulties in communication due to the loss of natural ear flaps. Dogs with cropped ears may also experience increased sensitivity.

Cropped ears can become infected, continue bleeding, cause the animal pain from sensitivity or phantom pain, and the success of surgery is never a guarantee. Amputation may be necessary in extreme cases, which comes with its own set of complications.

Infections can be severe, and in some cases, amputation of the ear is required. Your dog will lose an essential means of communication, and the risk of infection is a significant concern.

The erect appearance of cropped ears can pose more harm than benefit to the dog's overall well-being. This is especially true if the ears aren't set correctly, as they can heal in an unpleasant permanent position.

For another approach, see: Dogs Ears Cropped

Controversy and Debate

The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) has been opposed to ear cropping for cosmetic purposes since 1999, and they encourage the elimination of ear cropping from breed standards.

Credit: youtube.com, Controversial practice of dog ear cropping

Ear cropping is recognized in the American Kennel Club (AKC) breed standards for about 20 breeds of dogs, but it's not required for registration. Some breed standards list a preference for cropped ears, which can affect a dog's chances in conformation competition.

Many countries and regions are moving towards banning or discouraging ear cropping due to animal welfare concerns. In the United States, only nine states restrict the procedure, and no state completely bans it.

The Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in Australia and the United Kingdom, as well as most veterinary professional organizations, have taken stands against ear cropping.

Controversial

Ear cropping is a topic that sparks intense debate among dog enthusiasts and experts alike. The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) policy is to oppose ear cropping and tail docking when done solely for cosmetic purposes.

The American Kennel Club (AKC) recognizes ear cropping as an acceptable practice for certain breeds, but emphasizes that dogs with natural ears are not prohibited from entering dog shows. In fact, more and more "natural" dogs are being successfully shown, according to a Westminster spokesperson.

Most veterinary professional organizations around the world have issued statements opposing ear cropping, including the American Veterinary Medical Association and the American Animal Hospital Association. The Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in both Australia and the United Kingdom also take a stand against ear cropping.

Doctors Performing a Surgery in the Operating Room
Credit: pexels.com, Doctors Performing a Surgery in the Operating Room

Ear cropping has been banned in several countries, including Australia, most of Europe, and two Canadian provinces. In the United States, only nine states restrict the procedure, but no state completely bans it.

The AKC breed standards recognize ear cropping for about 20 breeds of dogs, but it's not required for registration. Some breed standards even list a preference for cropped ears, such as the Doberman Pinscher standard, which says "Ears normally cropped and carried erect."

SPCA Opposes Tail Docking

The SPCA-NN does not condone the practices of tail docking and ear cropping.

Cropping a dog's ears and docking tails causes harm to their physical and social well-being.

The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) opposes ear cropping for cosmetic purposes.

Many areas are moving toward banning or discouraging the practice due to animal welfare concerns.

The SPCA-NN's stance on tail docking is in line with the growing trend of prioritizing animal welfare.

Curious to learn more? Check out: Doberman Ear and Tail Cropping

Practical Considerations

Cropped ears can become infected if complications arise during the postoperative period.

Your dog will lose an essential means of communication if their ears aren't set correctly, and they can heal in an unpleasant permanent position.

Infections can be a serious issue if not caught early, so it's crucial to monitor your dog's ear health closely after surgery.

Practical Considerations

A Veterinarian Checking a Dog
Credit: pexels.com, A Veterinarian Checking a Dog

The ideal age for ear cropping depends on the breed and texture of ear cartilage, typically between 10-12 weeks for best results.

Ear cropping is allowed in dog shows, specifically for breeds where it's a standard practice. Many dog shows still uphold the tradition of ear cropping and tail docking.

The American Kennel Club recognizes ear cropping as an acceptable practice for certain breeds, provided it's done by a practicing veterinarian.

Ear cropping should be done by a veterinarian, not by dog owners or breeders themselves.

Dog Spaying/Neutering Considerations

Spaying or neutering your dog can be a big decision, and it's essential to consider the pros and cons before making a choice. Research has shown that early behavioral assessments can predict a dog's adult behavior, and some studies suggest that spaying or neutering can affect this development.

A study published in Plos ONE found that early behavioral assessments can be a reliable predictor of a dog's adult behavior. This is a crucial consideration when deciding whether to spay or neuter your dog.

Pet Owner Holding a Pomeranian Dog while Standing Beside the Veterinarian
Credit: pexels.com, Pet Owner Holding a Pomeranian Dog while Standing Beside the Veterinarian

The American Veterinary Medical Association recommends discussing the welfare implications of spaying or neutering with your veterinarian. This will help you make an informed decision that's best for your dog.

Spaying or neutering can prevent certain health issues, such as uterine infections and testicular cancer. However, it's essential to consider the potential risks and complications of the surgery itself.

The healing process after spaying or neutering can be lengthy and requires close attention from your veterinarian. This may involve multiple veterinary visits and a significant investment of time and resources.

Ultimately, the decision to spay or neuter your dog should be based on careful consideration of the benefits and risks, as well as your individual circumstances and goals for your dog.

Types of?

There are different types of ear crops, each depending on the dog's breed standards. Each style undergoes the same procedure.

You should never crop a dog's ears yourself, as it's a surgical procedure that must be performed under anesthesia, by a qualified veterinarian, and under strict sterile conditions.

Cost

Groomer Trimming Dog
Credit: pexels.com, Groomer Trimming Dog

Ear cropping can be a significant expense, but it's essential to consider the costs involved. Ear cropping ranges from $200 to $800, depending on the clinic, surgeon, and breed of dog.

If you're considering ear cropping for your dog, it's crucial to factor in the costs of the procedure. This can vary widely depending on the clinic and surgeon.

The cost of ear cropping can be broken down into several factors, including the breed of dog and the clinic. For example, ear cropping for some breeds, such as Doberman Pinschers, may be more expensive than for others.

Here is a rough estimate of the costs involved:

Keep in mind that these costs are only estimates and can vary depending on your location and the specific clinic you choose.

Do Dogs Help?

Dogs can be a great help in various ways, but it's essential to consider their needs and limitations.

Cropping a dog's ears doesn't improve their hearing or reduce ear infections, despite what some people might think.

Dogs can be trained to assist people with disabilities, such as guiding the blind or alerting the deaf. Their keen sense of smell can also be used for search and rescue missions.

However, dogs also require regular exercise and mental stimulation to stay happy and healthy.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does dog ear cropping cost?

Ear cropping costs start at $475. Contact Good Care Animal Clinic for more information on pricing and services.

Is dog ear cropping illegal in the US?

Dog ear cropping is not federally banned in the US, but some states have attempted to prohibit it due to health concerns. However, the American Kennel Club (AKC) still considers it an acceptable practice for certain breeds.

Erma Pacocha

Lead Writer

Erma Pacocha is a dedicated and passionate writer with a knack for crafting engaging content on a wide range of topics. Her expertise lies in the realm of animal care and welfare, where she has honed her skills in researching and writing about various breeds and their unique characteristics. With a focus on mixed-breed dogs, Erma has written extensively on the Pitbull Lab Mix, exploring its temperament, health, and training needs.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.