Barkbox vs Bullymake: Which Dog Subscription Box Is Best for Your Pet

If you're considering a dog subscription box, you're likely wondering which one is best for your furry friend. Barkbox and Bullymake are two popular options that offer unique features and benefits.

Barkbox offers a variety of toys and treats tailored to your dog's size, age, and dietary needs. With a focus on fun and play, Barkbox is a great choice for dogs that love to chew and play.

Bullymake, on the other hand, focuses on high-quality, durable toys that can withstand aggressive chewers. Their boxes also include a mix of healthy treats and chews.

When choosing a dog subscription box, consider the treats that come with it. Treats should make up no more than 10% of your dog's diet, according to Dr. Mondrian Contreras.

To ensure your dog doesn't have an adverse reaction to the treats, slowly integrate them into their diet and choose treats with ingredients and nutritional information printed on the label.

Sturdy toys are generally better for dogs, and those without small parts like buttons and googly eyes are a good option. Avoid toys that can be easily damaged by a dog's teeth.

For super chewers, durable rubber toys can be a good choice, but smaller pups may have trouble with these heavy-duty toys. The best dog subscription boxes provide options for pups of all sizes and chewing abilities.

It's essential to consider your dog's individual preferences when choosing a subscription box. As Erin Askeland says, "Sometimes there's a little bit of trial and error involved." You may want to start with a one-time box purchase before committing to a subscription.

Here's a breakdown of the types of toys you might find in a dog subscription box:

When evaluating dog subscription boxes, consider the types of toys they offer and whether they align with your dog's needs and preferences.

Barkbox and Bullymake are two popular subscription services that cater to dogs with a penchant for chewing. Both services offer a range of benefits, but there are some key differences to consider.

Barkbox and Bullymake offer a 1-month subscription for $45, which is the same price point for both services.

One of the main differences between the two services is the frequency of delivery. While Barkbox and Bullymake both offer a 1-month subscription, Bullymake also offers a 3-month subscription for $35, although Barkbox does not have this option.

Bullymake's 6-month subscription is priced at $33, which is slightly cheaper than Barkbox's 6-month subscription at $35. However, Barkbox's 12-month subscription is priced at $29, which is the same price point as Bullymake's 12-month subscription.

If you want to add an extra toy to your dog's box, both Barkbox and Bullymake charge $9 for this service.

Here's a comparison of the contents of each box:

Barkbox Super Chewer's box includes 2 toys and 2 bags of treats, while Bullymake's box includes 2-3 toys and 3 treats/chews. BoxDog's box includes a mix of treats, a specialty item, and toys or gear.

Barkbox Super Chewer offers free shipping within the contiguous 48 United States, while Bullymake offers free shipping within the United States. BoxDog offers free shipping to the continental United States.

Barkbox Super Chewer has a satisfaction guarantee that allows you to return any item at any time, while Bullymake's satisfaction guarantee is within 14 days. BoxDog does not have a satisfaction guarantee.

See what others are reading: Barkbox vs Super Chewer

When choosing between a BarkBox and a BullyMake Box, it's essential to consider what's inside. The Super Chewer BarkBox comes with two fluff-free toys.

Two full-size bags of treats are also included, along with two meaty, all-natural chews. This provides a good mix of variety and quantity for your dog.

The Bullymake box typically includes 2-3 tough chew toys and 3-4 bags of all-natural treats, making it a great option for dogs that love to chew.

Each Bullymake box comes with three packages of treats: two different small varieties and one larger one. These treats are perfect for use around the house or as a reward for good behavior.

The Kong Box, on the other hand, usually comes with one package of small treats that can be used for training. The Kong Box also includes the Sweet Potato spread, which can be used as a topper for Work-to-Eat projects.

Super Chewer BarkBox treats and chews are all-natural and made in the USA and Canada. They come in full-size bags and are personalized to fit the theme of the box.

The Super Chewer BarkBox also includes two meaty chews, such as crunchy beef trachea or chewy turkey sausages. These chews are a great option for dogs that love to chew on meaty treats.

In terms of toys, the Super Chewer BarkBox typically includes two fluff-free toys that are perfect for dogs that love to chew. The Bullymake box, on the other hand, usually includes 2-3 tough chew toys that are designed to withstand aggressive chewing.

Expand your knowledge: Mutt Dogs vs Purebred

Dogs come in all shapes and sizes, and their nutritional needs can vary depending on their breed or mix.

For small breeds like Chihuahuas, it's essential to feed them high-calorie foods to maintain their energy levels.

Some breeds, such as Bulldogs, can have difficulty breathing due to their flat faces, so their owners need to monitor their eating habits carefully.

Dogs with high energy levels, like Labradors, require more protein in their diet to keep them going.

Dogs with sensitive stomachs, such as Poodles, may need to stick to a limited ingredient diet to avoid digestive issues.

If this caught your attention, see: High Dog Barkbox

Super Chewer boxes contain 100% fluff-free toys made primarily with strong rubber and nylon.

The durable rubber used in Super Chewer toys can often withstand strong jaws, but smaller pups may have more trouble with these heavy-duty toys.

BULLYMAKE BOX toys typically consist of durable nylon and rubber, and customers can opt to receive toys made with rope or ballistic material.

For intense chewers, the super-tough nylon in the “XOXO” heart toy from BULLYMAKE holds its own, designed with a textured pattern on the surface.

Treats shouldn't make up more than 10% of your dog's diet, according to Dr. Mondrian Contreras, veterinarian and owner of Carol Stream Animal Hospital.

Toys that are too hard can damage a dog's teeth, so it's best to avoid them, and instead opt for sturdier toys that can withstand strong jaws.

The best dog toys will differ for each pup, but generally, sturdier toys are better, according to Erin Askeland, a professional dog trainer and animal health and behavioral expert for Camp Bow Wow.

Barkbox and Bullymake offer competitive pricing options for their subscription boxes. Barkbox starts at $29/month for a 12-month subscription, while Bullymake starts at $31/month for the same duration. Both services offer discounts for longer commitments, with Barkbox dropping to $35/month for a 6-month subscription and Bullymake's 6-month plan priced at $33/month.

Barkbox's pricing also includes a free month on any 6 or 12-month plan, while Bullymake offers a special price of $19 for the first box, with an additional $5 charge for the toy-only box. If your dog isn't a super chewer, Barkbox has a standard box option available.

Here's a comparison of the pricing options for both services:

The pricing for subscription boxes can be a bit confusing, but let's break it down. The first box of any subscription plan starts at a special price of $19, with an additional $5 charge for the toy-only box.

BarkBox Super Chewer starts at $29/month for a 12-month subscription, which is actually the same price as the monthly subscription plan without the special first-box discount.

If you're looking for a more affordable option, you can prepay for 3, 6, or 12 months and get a lower price per box: $35, $33, and $29 respectively.

Here's a quick rundown of the prices for different subscription plans:

Bullymake Box Pricing starts at $31/month for a 12-month subscription, which is a bit more expensive than BarkBox Super Chewer.

BULLYMAKE BOX offers a 14-Day Guarantee for their toys. This means they'll replace a toy if it's torn through by a power chewer within 14 days of receipt of shipment.

To qualify for a replacement, you'll need to submit a photo of the damaged toy. It's a simple process that will get your pup back to playing with a new favorite toy in no time.

They'll also help your pup find a replacement for toys that just don't get their tails wagging.

Bullymake offers a toy-only option, which can be a great value for pet owners who prioritize durable toys over treats. The price for Bullymake is not explicitly stated in the article section, but it mentions that they have competitive prices.

BarkBox Super Chewer, on the other hand, offers a more affordable option with a month-to-month plan of $45 per box, a 6-month subscription for $35 per box, and a 12-month subscription for $29 per box. These prices are more transparent than Bullymake's.

If you're looking for a subscription box that caters to allergies, both Bullymake and BarkBox Super Chewer have options that exclude beef, chicken, and turkey. Bullymake also offers a toy-only option, while BarkBox Super Chewer requires contacting customer service for this option.

Here are the pricing plans for BarkBox Super Chewer:

Both Bullymake and BarkBox Super Chewer offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee, which is a great feature for pet owners who want to ensure their pets are happy with their subscription boxes.

Bullymake is a popular choice for heavy chewers, offering a toy-only option and competitive prices. You can choose the toy materials your dog likes best and change the delivery frequency to every other month, once a quarter, or any other interval you prefer.

One of the best things about Bullymake is their toy variety, with four types of toys to choose from: nylon, rubber, rope, and ballistic. If your dog has a favorite toy type, you can stick with it, or mix and match to keep things interesting.

You can expect to receive four new Bullymake toys each month, which is perfect for power chewers like Barley. And with free shipping within the USA, you won't have to worry about extra costs.

**Comparison Table: Bullymake vs BarkBox Super Chewer**

Bullymake offers a convenient and flexible subscription service that caters to your dog's needs. You can cancel or change your subscription at any time, and their customer service is easily accessible through their website.

Bullymake is a great option for dog owners with heavy chewers. They offer a toy-only option, which is perfect for owners who can buy treats anywhere but struggle to find durable toys.

Their toys are made from high-quality materials like nylon, rubber, rope, and ballistic. You can choose the type of toys your dog likes best and even change the delivery frequency to suit your needs.

One of the best things about Bullymake is their customer service. They offer free shipping within the USA and will replace toys that are destroyed within 14 days.

BarkBox Super Chewer is another popular option, but it's a bit pricier than Bullymake. Each box includes 2 tough toys and 2 full-sized bags of treats made in the USA or Canada.

If you're looking for a more affordable option, BarkBox offers a 6-month and 12-month subscription plan that can save you some money. However, be aware that subscriptions automatically renew, making canceling necessary.

Here's a comparison of the pricing plans for Bullymake and BarkBox:

It's worth noting that Bullymake doesn't offer a multi-pet discount, but BarkBox does have a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

Overall, both Bullymake and BarkBox Super Chewer are great options for dog owners with heavy chewers. It's essential to consider your dog's preferences, budget, and needs before making a decision.

Signing up for a Bullymake box is a straightforward process. You can choose from a 12-month, 6-month, 3-month, or monthly subscription.

To get started, pick your plan on the Bullymake website. You can choose from a 12-month, 6-month, 3-month, or monthly subscription.

The first box ships on the next business day, with subsequent boxes shipping every 30 days thereafter. You can customize the delivery frequency to suit your needs.

You can also contact customer service to change the frequency of deliveries. Instead of receiving a box monthly, you could ask to receive one every other month, once a quarter, etc. You can also change the date you receive the boxes.

Here's a summary of the sign-up options:

You can choose the toy materials your dog likes best and change the delivery frequency to suit your needs.