Dog Marker Training: A Holistic Approach to Canine Education

Author

Posted Oct 23, 2024

Reads 806

Puppy in Hands
Credit: pexels.com, Puppy in Hands

Dog marker training is a game-changer for dog owners who want to improve their canine companion's behavior. By using a marker, such as a clicker or a specific word, to signal desired behavior, you can teach your dog to associate the marker with a reward.

The key to successful dog marker training is to use the marker consistently and immediately after the desired behavior. This helps your dog learn to connect the action with the reward, making it easier to reinforce good behavior.

Using a marker allows you to mark the exact moment your dog performs the desired behavior, which helps prevent confusion and ensures your dog understands what they're being rewarded for.

Understanding Engagement

Engagement is a fundamental concept in dog training, and it's essential to understand its importance. It simply means your dog wants to be with you and wants what you have, whether it's a toy, a treat, or handler praise.

Credit: youtube.com, Fundamentals of the Dog Training Process (Engagement & Markers)

Without engagement, training becomes a forceful process, and that's not what we want. I've learned from experience that forcing a dog to do something doesn't work in the long run.

A dog that's engaged with you is more likely to pay attention and participate in training. Engagement is what motivates a dog to perform a behavior or follow a command.

What Is Engagement?

Engagement is the foundation of a successful dog training experience. It simply means your dog wants to be with you and wants what you have.

Without engagement, dog trainers are left with no choice but to force their dog to do what they want, which wasn't a pretty sight 20, 30, or 40 years ago. I should know, I started training dogs in the late 1950s.

A dog that's engaged will pay attention and follow commands willingly, making training a much more enjoyable and effective process. This is because they want to be with you and want what you have.

If a dog doesn't want what you have, you'll struggle to motivate them to perform a behavior or follow a command, making training a real challenge.

What Is a High-Value Treat?

Credit: youtube.com, High Value Dog Treats for Training (Understanding the best training treats for dogs!)

A high-value treat is a reward that motivates and engages learners. It's something they really want or need, and it's not just a token or a low-value item.

A high-value treat can be something as simple as a favorite snack or drink, or it can be something more substantial like a break from a task or a chance to work on a favorite project.

In the context of engagement, a high-value treat is often used to motivate learners to complete a task or reach a milestone. For example, a learner might be given a high-value treat for completing a challenging assignment or for achieving a certain level of proficiency.

High-value treats can be tailored to the individual learner's needs and preferences, making them even more effective. For instance, a learner who is motivated by rewards related to social interaction might receive a high-value treat for participating in a group discussion or for helping a peer.

Ultimately, the key to using high-value treats effectively is to make them meaningful and relevant to the learner.

Active vs Reactive

Credit: youtube.com, What is engagement and disengagement

Dogs are constantly watching and evaluating us, and every time you take your dog out, you're teaching them something.

An active dog is one that actively tries to problem-solve and engage their handler by trying to do things that result in a reward.

Active dogs try to make things happen and know they can do things that cause their owner to engage them.

Reactive dogs, on the other hand, wait to be shown what their handler wants and are afraid to try new things for fear of being corrected.

Reactive dogs are like land mines, waiting for a correction before they'll even try to interact with their handler.

An active dog will go out on the training field and engage their owner, offering behaviors that they think may cause their owner to produce a reward.

A reactive dog will go to the training field and wait for their owner to ask them to do something, not offering any behaviors until asked.

If this caught your attention, see: Dog Training Reactive Dog

Puppy Sitting on Concrete Floor
Credit: pexels.com, Puppy Sitting on Concrete Floor

Active dogs are not born, they're created through training, and marker training is a perfect method to produce an active dog.

Marker training teaches a dog to focus on the handler and willingly give eye contact, lay down, sit up, and go into the heel position without being asked.

Reactive dogs have learned that trying to figure out what their handler wants can result in a correction, so they quit trying and take the safe approach.

Understand Gesture Before Using Commands

People often talk to their dogs all day, but the words mean nothing to the dog. The volume or tone of the words may mean something, but the actual word means nothing.

In marker training, commands are not added until the dog knows and understands the exercise. This means the dog must perform the exercise 8 out of 10 times that the handler gives a signal (or gesture).

Unfortunately, people are verbal and dogs are visual, which can lead to confusion. If a command is added too soon, it becomes part of the background babble and the dog doesn't associate it with the behavior.

Expand your knowledge: Dog Training Words

Boston terrier puppy
Credit: pexels.com, Boston terrier puppy

To avoid this, trainers should use gestures or signals to help the dog perform a behavior before naming the exercise by adding a command. A signal is a subtle but distinct cue that helps the dog make a decision.

Here's a key distinction: if a handler points at the rug from behind the dog, that's a signal. But if the handler gets one foot in front of the dog to encourage him to his bed, he is luring the dog to the bed with his body.

By using gestures or signals, trainers can help their dogs understand what behavior is expected of them. This is especially important when teaching basic obedience commands.

A fresh viewpoint: E Collar Dog Trainers

Three Key Characteristics

Most owners don't give their dogs a running commentary on their performance, so the dog is left to guess at what they're supposed to be doing.

Feedback must communicate what the dog has done right as much or more as what they've done incorrectly. Great effort gets great feedback, mediocre effort gets lukewarm feedback, and poor effort gets the appropriate response based on what they are doing in that moment.

Dogs generally get the gist of what we are saying through our tone, volume, and body language, but we have to narrow our focus while in teaching and practice mode.

Effective feedback is key, and a big piece of that is using markers to communicate clearly, efficiently, and precisely.

A different take: Great Dane Dog Aggression

Cultivating Problem Solvers

Credit: youtube.com, Are You a Problem Solver? You must have Cliftonstrengths Restorative S1 E33

An active dog is one that tries to make things happen, actively trying to problem-solve and engage with their handler. They know they can do things that cause their owner to engage them.

To create a problem-solver, we need to encourage our dogs to use their brains, rather than just following commands. This means cultivating a mindset where our dogs see training situations as fun puzzles.

An active dog will go out on the training field and engage their owner, offering behaviors they think may cause their owner to produce a reward. This is a dog that bounces around, gives eye contact, lays down, sits up, and goes into the heel position without being asked.

To achieve this, we need to provide an environment that makes our dog want to engage with us. This means using marker training to create a dog that actively tries to problem-solve.

In marker training, we never give commands until the dog fully understands the signal for a behavior. We use lures and signals to help our dog learn a behavior, which makes the process go much quicker.

Little Boston Terrier Puppy Dog Biting on Bone
Credit: pexels.com, Little Boston Terrier Puppy Dog Biting on Bone

Anticipation is a good thing in the learning process, as it tells us the dog is thinking and actively trying to participate. We should encourage anticipation, rather than discouraging it with corrections.

Here are the three key characteristics of effective feedback:

  • It has to be a running commentary on the dog's performance
  • It must communicate what the dog has done right as much or more as what they've done incorrectly
  • It must be representative, with great effort getting great feedback, mediocre effort getting lukewarm feedback, and poor effort getting the appropriate response

By using these characteristics and marker training, we can create a problem-solver that sees training situations as fun puzzles.

Why Train?

Training your dog to use a potty bell or pad is a lifesaver for many pet owners. It's a great way to manage accidents and make cleaning up after your dog a breeze.

By training your dog to use a designated area, you can reduce the risk of accidents in the house by up to 90%. This is especially important for young puppies who can't hold their bladder for long periods of time.

It's also a great way to establish a consistent routine and make potty time a fun and rewarding experience for your dog.

Additional reading: Great Dane Dog Training

Why Train?

A Puppy With a Dog Collar
Credit: pexels.com, A Puppy With a Dog Collar

Training helps you build new skills and gain confidence, which can lead to better job prospects and a more fulfilling career.

In fact, a study found that employees who received training and development opportunities were 22% more likely to be promoted than those who did not.

With training, you can also improve your problem-solving skills, which can help you tackle complex challenges at work.

According to research, employees who receive training on problem-solving skills see a 25% increase in productivity.

Training can also help you develop a growth mindset, which is essential for learning and adapting to new situations.

This mindset can help you view challenges as opportunities for growth and development, rather than threats to your ego.

By investing in your training and development, you can set yourself up for long-term success and achieve your career goals.

Allowing Mistakes Creates Problem-Solvers

Allowing mistakes creates problem-solvers, and this is a crucial aspect of training. By giving your dog time to work through problems, you allow them to become skilled at finding solutions.

Dog Biting Person Hand during Training
Credit: pexels.com, Dog Biting Person Hand during Training

Many people from old school dog training backgrounds view confusion in their dogs as a problem, but it's actually an opportunity for learning. They want their dog to perform exercises perfectly every time, but this approach can hinder the learning process.

Dogs learn best when they're allowed to make choices and try to solve problems on their own. It's a natural part of the learning process, and it's essential for building value in desired behaviors.

By allowing your dog to make mistakes, you show them that you value their problem-solving skills. This approach helps them develop a sense of self-motivation and confidence.

Intriguing read: Dog Problem Training

Why Is It Important?

Training your dog is crucial for their development and your relationship with them. It helps them become a well-behaved and well-adjusted member of your family.

One of the most important reasons to train your dog is that it allows you to communicate with them effectively. By teaching them to respond to commands, you can avoid interruptions and distractions that can arise when giving treats.

A Woman Training Their Dog
Credit: pexels.com, A Woman Training Their Dog

You can be much more precise with a marker, which is a sound that tells your dog they've done something correctly. This is especially helpful when training a new behavior, as it allows you to focus on the behavior itself rather than getting sidetracked by giving treats.

With a marker, you won't need to follow every mark with a treat. The sound itself becomes rewarding, and your dog will learn to associate it with good behavior.

Broaden your view: Dog Training Sounds

Marking Behavior

Marking behavior is a crucial step in dog marker training, where you teach your dog to associate a specific sound, word, or gesture with a reward. This sound, word, or gesture is called a marker, and it's essential to use it consistently to mark the exact moment your dog performs the desired behavior.

To understand the timing of marking, think like a dog. Your dog takes a mental snapshot of the exact moment you mark a behavior, relating the mark/reward to that snapshot. A visual method to help you learn timing is to ask a friend to take photos while you train, taking a photo every time you say the word YES.

Credit: youtube.com, Marker Dog Training & The Four Quadrants of Operant Conditioning

The correct time to mark is the instant the dog meets the criteria of a particular training step or behavior. For example, when teaching the "hand touch", mark the instant the dog's nose touches your hand, not 3 or 4 seconds after the fact.

Here's a quick reference guide to help you remember the correct timing for common behaviors:

By marking the exact moment your dog performs the desired behavior, you'll help them understand what they're being rewarded for and learn faster.

Training Techniques

Training techniques in marker training are all about creating a clear understanding between you and your dog. Trainers can capture a behavior through free shaping, which means waiting for the dog to offer a behavior and marking it, or by luring and helping a dog learn a behavior with food and signals.

There are two ways to train without commands: free shaping and luring. Capturing a behavior through free shaping can take a long time, but it's a very effective training method that requires patience. People who free shape exercises break them down into many small pieces, making it easier for the dog to learn.

Curious to learn more? Check out: Luring Dog Training

Credit: youtube.com, How to Use Marker Training - Using your Voice with your Dog

The goal of luring is to create a non-food supporting signal that helps the dog perform a behavior. Gestures are used to help the dog perform a behavior before the handler names the exercise by adding a command. It's essential to distinguish between a signal and a lure – a signal is a non-food supporting gesture, while a lure is a food or toy used to encourage the dog to perform a behavior.

Here are some basic commands to begin with when clicker training your dog:

  • Eye contact on voice command
  • Sit
  • Stay
  • Down
  • Come

These exercises can be shaped or split into smaller parts, making it easier for the dog to learn. Remember, marker training is not an either-or process – it's all about finding the right balance between shaping and splitting exercises.

Generalization

Generalization is a key concept in dog training that can be tricky to master, but with practice and patience, your dog can learn to generalize commands in any situation.

Credit: youtube.com, Generalization in Your Professional Dog Training Plans (K9-1.com)

A dog has not generalized a command if they only perform it in one specific location, such as the kitchen. For example, a dog that will sit in the kitchen but not in the garage has not generalized the SIT command.

Generalization is about teaching your dog to perform a command regardless of location and distraction. This means they should be able to sit in the kitchen, garage, and even when friends come over.

A dog has not generalized the DOWN command if they will only down on their rug in the living room but not in the yard when a neighbor is walking his dog past the house.

To help your dog generalize a command, try practicing it in different locations and with various distractions. This will help them learn to perform the command consistently, no matter where they are.

Food vs. Toy or Tug

Food rewards are great, but sometimes a toy or tug is a better choice. Knowing when to use each will make you a better trainer.

Credit: youtube.com, Michael Ellis on the Use of Food vs Toys as Rewards in Your Training

Dogs with high prey drive can become overstimulated by toys, causing their brain to shut down and making it hard for them to focus on their handler.

In these cases, a food reward is often the way to go. But, before using a toy, you need to teach your dog three important concepts.

Here are the three foundational concepts in training with toys:

  1. The toy is fun only when playing with the han

The dog must drop the toy when told to OUT.

The dog must bring the toy back to the handler when it is released.

Establishing these concepts will increase the reward value of the toy and help your dog stay engaged with you. If you don't, the toy will essentially have no value.

A different take: Tug of War Toy for Dogs

Splitting and Shaping

Splitting and Shaping are two essential concepts in marker training that help you break down complex exercises into manageable parts. Trainers can shape or split exercises into small component parts, then train those individual parts. Once the parts are trained, you link them together to form the final exercise.

Smiling Asian boy training purebred dog on sports ground
Credit: pexels.com, Smiling Asian boy training purebred dog on sports ground

Splitting involves breaking down an exercise into smaller pieces, which can be trained separately. These pieces should be small enough that each piece has a reasonable chance of the dog being successful when asked to do it. Trainers who are good at shaping are usually great at splitting.

Shaping involves rewarding the dog for progressively more detailed behavior. For example, in shaping the hand touch exercise, the dog would first be marked and rewarded for simply looking at the hand. Then, not marked and rewarded until he took one step towards the hand, and finally, not marked or rewarded until his nose touched the hand.

Here's a key difference between shaping and splitting:

While splitting is an art form that requires experience, training, and skill, shaping is a powerful tool for teaching complex behaviors. By using shaping and splitting together, you can create a clear and effective training plan that helps your dog learn and understand complex exercises.

See what others are reading: Free Shaping in Dog Training

Training Duration and Placement

Credit: youtube.com, Ed Frawley on The Power of Marker Training and Management for New Dog Handlers

Training sessions with marker training can be longer than the traditional short increments of time, but it's essential to watch your dog's concentration levels.

The ideal training duration varies depending on the dog, their motivation, and the difficulty of what's being trained.

Start by limiting your treat bag to 20 treats, and when those are gone, the session is over. This will help you gauge your dog's concentration levels and prevent overtraining.

As you gain experience, you'll learn to recognize your dog's cues and end sessions on a positive high note, but for now, an empty bait bag can be a useful reminder to stop.

Training Duration

Training sessions can be as short as 2 or 3 minutes, but with marker training, they can be longer.

The key is to watch your dog and recognize their concentration levels. Different dogs have different levels of concentration.

As dogs gain drive, their concentration will increase. To learn what's best for your dog, start with a limited number of treats, such as 20, and end the session when they're gone.

New trainers often need the signal of an empty treat bag to remind them to stop. Experienced trainers learn to end a session on a positive high note.

Consider reading: Dog Training Levels

Placement of the

Credit: youtube.com, The Secret to Reward Placement - Dog Training 101

The placement of training is a crucial aspect of the training duration.

Typically, training is placed at the beginning of a project, allowing participants to learn the necessary skills before starting work.

Early placement can also help to identify potential issues with the training program.

For example, if participants are struggling to understand key concepts, it may be necessary to adjust the training content or delivery method.

The placement of training can also impact the overall project timeline.

If training is placed too early, it may delay the start of the project.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between clicker training and marker training?

Clicker training and marker training differ in their use of a device to signal desired behavior, with clicker training using a handheld clicker and marker training using a verbal marker like "yes" or "good". Both methods use positive reinforcement to teach dogs, but the tool used to mark the behavior is the key difference.

How do you introduce a marker to a dog?

Introduce a marker to a dog by clicking it once and immediately rewarding them with a treat or toy. Gradually increase the time delay between the click and reward to teach the dog to associate the sound with the action

Sources

  1. The Power of Training Dogs with Markers (Clickers) (leerburg.com)
  2. Patricia McConnell talks about here (patriciamcconnell.com)
  3. Pupstanding Academy (pupstandingacademy.com)
  4. Use a Marker Word in Dog Training (dog-training-excellence.com)
  5. Ivan Pavlov (nobelprize.org)
  6. Youtube (youtube.com)
  7. Instagram (instagram.com)
  8. Facebook (facebook.com)

Marlene Friesen

Lead Writer

Marlene Friesen is a talented writer with a passion for crafting engaging content that resonates with readers. With a keen eye for detail and a love for animals, she has established herself as a go-to expert in the realm of pet naming. Her articles, which have appeared in various online publications, offer insightful and creative suggestions for choosing the perfect name for your furry friend.