Ear cropping, a surgical procedure to remove part of a Rottweiler's ears, has been a long-standing practice in the breed.
In many countries, ear cropping is considered a cosmetic procedure and is not medically necessary.
Rottweilers are prone to ear infections, and ear cropping can reduce the risk by eliminating the floppy ear structure that traps moisture and bacteria.
However, some argue that ear cropping can lead to complications, such as pain, infection, and scarring.
The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) has stated that ear cropping is a cosmetic procedure and not a necessity.
Check this out: Doberman Pinscher Not Cropped
Why Do People Crop a Dog's Ears?
People crop a dog's ears for cosmetic reasons, which is a false reason. They want to give the dog a scarier look, especially in breeds like Rottweilers. Rottweilers with cropped ears are more intimidating and imposing. In fact, some dog owners choose to crop their Rottweilers' ears to achieve this effect.
Rottweilers with cropped ears are less likely to win in competitions because it's not included in the international standard for the breed. This is in contrast to other breeds like Dobermans, which look distinctly less scary with floppy ears. Rottweilers are already incredibly powerful dogs with a strong bite.
On a similar theme: When Is It Too Late to Crop a Dog's Ears?
Ear cropping involves surgically removing part of the ear flaps in young puppies, usually between 5 weeks for small dogs and 9 to 12 weeks for larger breeds. This procedure is associated with making dogs look vicious or intimidating, and it's mostly used for "status or weapon dogs".
Ear cropping is waning in popularity as more people question its need and whether it's in the dog's best interests. Most people and veterinarians agree that it's unnecessary and even cruel to remove a piece of the dog's anatomy just for the purpose of looks.
For more insights, see: Why Is My Dog's Ears Cold?
The Controversy Surrounding
Ear cropping, a practice that involves surgically removing part of a dog's ear flaps, has been a topic of debate for many years. Most of the historical reasons for ear cropping have been proven false or are no longer relevant today.
Dogfighting, one of the original reasons for ear cropping, is prohibited in many countries. Hounds, for example, are commonly used for hunting and chasing down prey, and their long ears actually aid in scent trailing.
The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) opposes ear cropping when it's done solely for cosmetic reasons. In fact, the AVMA considers ear cropping to be unnecessary and even cruel.
In Germany, where ear cropping is believed to have originated, it is actually illegal. The practice remains legal in the United States and most of Canada, despite opposition from many veterinarians and animal welfare organizations.
Here are some countries and states that have banned or limited ear cropping:
- Australia
- New Zealand
- Some parts of Canada
- Some American states like Connecticut, Maryland, New York, New Hampshire, and Pennsylvania limit ear cropping unless performed by a licensed vet under anesthesia
- UK (unless under the vet's discretion)
Some people believe ear cropping can prevent ear infections or injuries, but this is completely untrue. In reality, ear cropping can actually be detrimental to a dog's health, behavior, and welfare.
Should I Crop My Dog's Ears?
Ear cropping for dogs is a surgical procedure that can be painful, and proper veterinary care can help reduce the pain and risk of infection.
Most states still have veterinarians who offer ear cropping services, so it's worth doing your homework and consulting with a veterinarian or getting a few opinions first.
Any surgery, including ear cropping, requires careful consideration and aftercare.
Pico Rivera Animal Hospital is happy to discuss the risks and aftercare with you, but they don't perform ear cropping for dogs.
It's essential to weigh the potential benefits against the potential risks and decide what's best for you and your dog.
Medical Reasons
Ear cropping is a practice that's been around for a long time, and some people still think it's necessary for a Rottweiler's health.
The idea that ear cropping prevents ear infections is a myth with no solid scientific evidence to back it up. This claim is often used to justify the procedure, but it's simply not true.
In fact, some breeds that are prone to ear infections, like German Shepherds and Beagles, are not cropped. This suggests that ear cropping is more about appearances than actual health benefits.
Dogs that are used for illegal dog fighting may also have their ears cropped, but this is not a reason to crop a Rottweiler's ears if you're not planning to use them for fighting.
Intriguing read: Bullmastiff vs Rottweiler
Risks and Concerns
Cropping a Rottweiler's ears can be a painful procedure for the dog. The wounds can take a long time to heal, requiring a lot of aftercare.
Infection is a significant risk, especially if the wound becomes contaminated. The anesthesia used during the procedure can also pose dangers.
The healing process is still painful, even with anesthesia, and can be especially difficult for older puppies past 4 months due to stronger cartilage.
Risks and Concerns
Cropping a Rottweiler's ears poses the risk of infection. This can be a serious concern, especially if the wounds become infected easily.
Ear cropping can be very painful for dogs, and the wounds can take a long time to heal. This requires a lot of aftercare, including changing dressings and cleaning.
The healing process for cropped ears is still painful, even with anesthesia during the procedure. This is especially true for older puppies past 4 months.
Anesthesia dangers are another risk associated with ear cropping. This is a concerning aspect of the procedure, as it poses a risk to the dog's health.
The wounds from ear cropping can become infected easily, which can lead to serious health issues. This is a significant concern for dog owners who consider ear cropping.
Curious to learn more? Check out: Dog Ear Health
Infections
Ear infections are a significant risk associated with ear cropping. Ear infections can occur due to improper aftercare, even if the procedure is performed correctly.
Signs of ear infections include redness, itchiness, discharge, scabs, and discomfort. Infections can also occur due to microbes entering the wounds during the procedure if a professional didn't perform it.
Dogs like German Shepherds, who are prone to otitis externa, are not typically cropped, suggesting that ear cropping may not be an effective way to prevent infections.
You might enjoy: Ear Infections in Goldendoodles
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it cruel to crop a dog's ears?
Cropping a dog's ears can be detrimental to their health, behavior, and welfare. It's a cosmetic procedure that prioritizes appearance over the dog's well-being.
Sources
- https://www.picoriveravet.com/site/blog/2022/10/30/ear-cropping-dogs
- https://pawsafe.com/blogs/dog-healthcare/rottweilers-cut-ears
- https://www.rspca.org.uk/adviceandwelfare/pets/dogs/health/earcropping
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4922641/
- https://www.alanastevenson.com/ear-cropping-and-tail-docking-dogs/
Featured Images: pexels.com